Registration with

register

lost password recovery

recover my password

sign in

  • If you registered before August, 2014, you will need to register again. Sorry for the inconvenience.
  • remember me
sign in

Suggest a Songfact / Artistfact

Sign up for our newsletter

Get the Newsletter

Tin Man by America

Album: HolidayReleased: 1974Charted:
4
  • This song is about eschewing love for sex, which is the "perfect prize that waits among the shells," for which the bait is a quick, loveless seduction, while real love is the real reward. And anyone who remembers The Wizard of Oz knows that the Tin Man really wanted a heart, which the Wizard showed him he already had. (thanks, S.D. - Denver, CO)
or Register to post comments

Comments: 11

On August 18th 1974, "Tin Man" by America entered Billboard's Hot Top 100 chart at position #89; and on November 3rd, 1974 it peaked at #4 {for 3 weeks} and spent 18 weeks on the Top 100...
On September 29th, 1974 it reached #1 {for 1 week} on Billboard's Adult Contemporary Tracks chart {their next release, "Lonely People", also peak at #1 on the Adult chart}...
Between 1972 and 1983 the trio had seventeen Top 100 records; seven made the Top 10 with two reaching #1, "A Horse With A Name" for 3 weeks on March 19th, 1972 and "Sister Golden Hair" for 1 week on June 8th, 1975...
R.I.P. Dan Peek {November 1st, 1950 - July 24th, 2011}.
Barry - Sauquoit, Ny
Let's just go to the source shall we? Highway Highlight (from the box set booklet)
Bunnell's "Tin Man" was released as Holiday's first single, reaching #4 in the fall of '74. The song was a return to the soaring melodicism of "Ventura Highway," and it reestablished America on the airwaves. Still, Dewey has mixed feelings about "Tin Man": "The song is jumbled in my mind--there's not a lot of cohesiveness. I had really liked the chords, those major-sevenths. It was up and kind of bouncy, with a little Latin-y feel to it. That's how it is: I get the chords and the melody, and then I have to get some words."

Bunnell unravels the lyric as follows: "My favorite movie of all time was probably The Wizard Of Oz, it still amazes me how great that movie is. And here's my classic use of bad grammar: 'Oz never did give nothing to the Tin Man...' Another god-awful use of the language. But it served the purpose. But that was really the only cohesive thought I had. How do I convey that? The first verse--I guess that was a little bit of paranoia. We were being exposed to more and more sophisticated people, and there were times that I found myself with my foot in my mouth, saying things I wish I hadn't. The first verse is very ambiguous. 'The Tropic of Sir Gallahad' is a whole other image to me about being chivalrous or a gentleman. 'Spinning round, round, round, smoke glass stain bright colors...'--that's all just purely kaleidoscopic imagery. The melody definitely dictated those words, because it was a swirling, rising thing." (so sorry kids that always try to equate songs to drugs.) Dewey tended to write lyrics to fit the music. There wasn't always a literal meaning.
Djflwb - Tampa, Fl
Wasn't this group high all the time. LolJodie - Xxxxx, Md
I have looked at these lyrics a bit. Here is my take: Guy goes to a party, and as inhibitions drop and minds expand, talk gets a bit philosophical as per usual. The prize among the shells is from the old street corner "shell game" you've seen live or for sure in a movie, in this case making a profoundly insightful point to a bunch of drunks. The protagonist doesn't care too much for that, and dismissively comes out with the trite "Tin Man/ Oz" statement. Now here is what I think the next and most perplexing lines mean: Since the word "Cause" is capitalized in most of the lyrics for this I see posted, I assume "Primal Cause", which may be scientific or religious in nature (Why are we here? What does it all mean? etc.). But who wants to talk about that...I'm here to party! The next line is easy to interpret once you know that a rather obscure meaning of the word "tropic" is "allegory" or "metaphor". Certainly Arthurian legend is loaded with these, one of the more notable being Sir Galahad. But forget all the talk...Let's just enjoy the ride!Rupert - Sa;esville, Wi
Why do you insist that these lyrics have meaning? I don't know but I suspect they are gibberish. Oftentimes, song writers will develop the melody without lyric and substitute gibberish with the intention of returning later and writing something "appropriate". Given the culture of the mid-70's when this was written and their youth, it is completely conceivable to me that Dewey was just bein' screwy. ;)

Most importantly, keep in mind that these are the same guys who wrote: The ocean is a desert with its life underground and the perfect disguise above.
Jim - London, On
S.D. from Denver is correct. You must remember that when this song was released it was illegal for artist to talk about drugs and sex.Roberta - Bakersfield, Ca
Really deep lyrics, mannnnnnnn....Esskayess - Dallas, Tx
I agree with Charlotte. I have always felt that the song meant that. People's egos always go in the "left field" late drinking and having a good time. And, there's usually one on the sidelines with the lyrics going through his head while just shaking his head back and forth. Right on, Charlotte!Jibri - Muskegon, Mi
I like what you wrote below, Charlotte. I basically agree. I've been singing these lyrics for years and never really understood them myself...Johnnys Cousin Steve - Villas, Nj
First Verse: "Sometimes late when things are real And people share the gift of gab between themselves Some are quick to take the bait
And catch the perfect prize that waits among the shelves"

I think is about people sitting around late at night (maybe doing drugs/coke) talking crap about other people and just running their mouths about things that are just not that interesting or important.

Second verse/chorus: "But Oz never did give nothing to the Tin Man That he didn't, didn't already have And Cause never was the reason for the evening Or the tropic of Sir Galahad"

He can think for his self what he wants to about the people (or the subjects) and does not need or care about their gossip that has nothing to do with anything important. So he starts to get bored.

3rd Verse:"So please believe in me When I say I'm spinning round, round, round, round Smoke glass stain bright color Image going down, down, down, down Soapsuds green like bubbles"

He is just looking at all the smoke & glass listeing to everyone talk s--t and his mind is going off in to some type of psychedlic trip cause he could care less about all the gossip.

"And Cause never was the reason for the evening Or the tropic of Sir Galahad" kind of reminds me when my Dad used to tell me "What the hell does that have to do with the price of beans in China?"
Charlotte - Houston, Tx
So. . . what's all the mularkey about this: "Cause never was the reason for the evening, or the Tropic of Sir Galahad."

Talk about yer confoosin' lyrics! Sheesh!

David
Suwanee, GA
David - Lynn, Massachusetts, Ma