lost password recovery

recover my password

Suggest a Songfact / Artistfact

sign in

Sign up for our newsletter

Get the Newsletter

Shine On You Crazy Diamond by Pink Floyd

Album: Wish You Were HereReleased: 1975
  • This is a tribute to Syd Barrett, an original member of Pink Floyd - notice the title, Shine On You Crazy Diamond. He was their lead guitarist and wrote most of their early hits, but he gradually went nuts and was kicked out of the band in 1968, three years after the group started. Drugs played a big role in his mental illness.
  • During the final mixing sessions of this song in June of 1975, Barrett wandered into the studios, ready to help out. He was fat, bald, and as crazy as they remembered, but they let him stay for a while. Barrett wanted to rejoin the group, but they learned in 1967 and 1968 that having an insane member was not good for a band. Before he was kicked out, Barrett would get on stage and either refuse to play or play the same note over and over.
  • According to the Pink Floyd autobiography A Saucerful of Secrets by Nicholas Schaffner, when Barrett came into the control room, the remaining members of Pink Floyd were listening to the finished recording of the album. This was the eve before Pink Floyd were going on a US tour. David Gilmour didn't recognize him at first - they hadn't seen him in years. Syd was fat, bald, had shaved eyebrows and was wearing a white trenchcoat with white shoes. When someone tried to break the ice by asking Syd how he had put on so much weight, he maniacally replied, "I've got a very large fridge in the kitchen, and I've been eating a lot of pork chops!" That was the last time any of the Pink Floyd members have seen him. . >>
    Suggestion credit:
    Dave - Marieta, GA
  • Gilmour came up with four notes that became the basis for this. Roger Waters thought they conveyed emotions Barrett must have been feeling, and wrote lyrics about him.
  • Waters sang lead. He recorded the vocal line by line over and over again, and killed his voice in the process. That's why English folk singer Roy Harper was brought in to sing "Have A Cigar." He was close friend of the band's, as well as Led Zeppelin. >>
    Suggestion credit:
    Adrian - Brookings, SD
  • On the album Wish You Were Here, this is split into two parts, with "Have A Cigar," "Welcome To The Machine," and "Wish You Were Here" in between. It was going to be continuous, but Waters decided it should be split.
  • This was very difficult to record. They redid it a few times before getting a version they liked.
  • Dick Parry was brought in to play sax on this. He also played on "Us And Them" and "Money" from Dark Side of the Moon.
  • Pink Floyd started playing this live over a year before the album came out. The band thought they could improve on songs if they played them at concerts before recording them. At the time, it was known as "Shine On."
  • This was the last song Richard Wright got a writing credit for before Roger Waters kicked him out of the band during The Wall sessions 4 years later. A combination of Waters' increasing control over the group and Wright's mounting personal problems are what led to his departure. He would not rejoin the band until 1987, after Waters himself had left. >>
    Suggestion credit:
    Adrian - Brookings, SD
  • In 1986, Waters left the band and became enraged when they continued on without him. At subsequent Pink Floyd shows, they played this with Gilmour on vocals.
  • In The Simpsons episode "The Old Man and Lisa," Monty Burns meets a hippy at a recycling center and says to him, "Shine on you crazy diamond." >>
    Suggestion credit:
    Tom - Mendon, MA
Sign in or Register to post comments

Comments: 127

Waters sang lead. He recorded the vocal line by line over and over again, and killed his voice in the process. That's why English folk singer Roy Harper was brought in to sing "Have A Cigar." He was close friend of the band's, as well as Led Zeppelin. (thanks, Adrian - Brookings, SD)

That is partially the story. The real story was that both David Gilmour and Roger Waters recorded vocal parts for this song. Neither version seemed to work. Roy Harper was recording music in another room that day and came in to watch Pink Floyd record for a bit. He noticed they were having trouble with the track and decided to give it a shot by recording his own voice. The band liked it but Roger Waters was a bit jealous. They kept Roy Harper's version though regardless of Waters thought.
Josh - Miami, Fl
In the beginning guitar lead of the song David Gilmour plays four distinct notes. If you say "Are you out there" as he is playing the notes, it just seems to fit. Does anyone know if this is what Mr. Gilmour was trying to accomplish?Doug - Michigan, Usa
Speechless, one of the best pieces of music ever written! what a song, what an album!Darren - Auckland, New Zealand
My theory is Syd Barret was a targeted individual "Cointelpro" government mind control and testing of LSD. Just as it is now... no one knew!Greg - Mackinaw, Il
I may be only 14 years old, but that doesn't mean that I'm ignorant to music such as this and its significant impact on everyone that commented. Honestly, I stumbled upon this song about a year ago while looking up long songs. I listened to it and instantly loved it. Not just it, but all of Pink Floyd's music, and the psychadelic rock genre in general. I plan on having 2 songs play at my funeral: this and Movin' On Up by Primal Scream. I may not have been around for much of this music, and had no clue who Syd Barrett or Richard Wright were when they died, but I still love this music and will continue to until the day I die.Geoff - Tionesta Twp., Pa
It was this song that invented the Internet.......... not Al Gore.Crash - Falmouth, Ma
The Irish musician Christy Moore has an interesting cover version of this tune on his 2009 album "Listen".Ed - Lebanon, Nh
thank you Pink Floyd, thats all i have to sayJohn - Brownsvalley, Ca
many of the words "threatened by shadows at night/exposed in the light", "you reached for the secret too soon" are about secrets of life and many experiences that LSD gives youTravis - Mission Viejo, Ca
Rune Hoel from Norway you are an absolute inspiration, and a true student of life. Your testimony is completely understandable and is truly eye opening. What you wrote should be an eye opener for people who take their health and sanity for granted. Your words sound like something Roger Waters might have written. I hope you read this and understand that you are not alone and you are a very valuable part of this world we all share. My friend as the late great Jim Morrison said, "when the music's over, turn off the lights".Arturo - Brownsville, Tx
I got inot Pink Floys when my brother recently passed away and I had to organise his funeral - I didn't play SOYCD due to parents probably not getting it (Wish you here instead). I bought all the later Floyd albums to pick a song from but it occurs to me that SOYCD is not really a tribute to Syd but about being sad and angry about what he did to himself and taking his genious away from them and the world - just my thoughts - I feel a lot of anger in the lyrics of this song and sadness in the solos.Deb - Brisbane, Australia
This is the truth of my life situation. This is my reality. I am now being in grown up age a psycaiatric pasient. I could get schizofrenia out of my background with this truth. Now I am seeking some of my thruth of my background. This is a my key for heaven, hou I was in my youth, why I am clean to past the gate after I have passed away. Rune HoelRune - Kirkenes, Norway
In the intro, one can briefly make out the sound of tuned crystal wine goblets being played. It blends wonderfully with the synth so as to almost be indistinguishable, but that's why the live intros never sound exactly the same as the album. For a brief period after Dark Side,while trying to figure out what to do for a followup, the band toyed with the idea of a project called "Household Objects" which involved making music with non-instruments such as crystal goblets, giant elastic bands and rolls of tape. The only usable sounds were the ones the wine goblets made, so they incorporated that beautiful noise into the intro of Shine On. In 2006, David re-introduced this concept on the last few performances of his tour and you can see them playing the Shine On intro on wineglasses on the DVD. Pretty cool. And veeeeeery Floyd.Terry - Wickford, Ri
I remember getting this album the day it came out, setting up the speakers in the window, laying out in the side yard, blowing a joint with my friend and firing up the music. Truly amazing. Saw them on "Animals" (terrible album) at MSG and "The Wall" (claustrophobic/paranoid/disturbia classic) at the old Nassau Coliseum. Cannot believe the video clip from the PULSE concert stops just after the vocals start - what a rip!Mike - Stratford, Ct
By far, the best tune, from the best album, from not only this band, but any band that ever existed.
Just as sad, as it is true, Syd was a tripster casualty. Both David and Roger worked on this one as a tribute,this was absotulely the peak of the band, and it's never been the same since.It just don't get any better than this. Period.
Harold - Detroit, Mi
thats "Soon after dark, Emily cries", oldpink. cant describe this song. Ive been trying to figure out how to comment and i cant. so why am i talking? i dont know, dont ask me.Chloe - St. Louis, Mo
One small note I forgot is that, at the very end of the song, Rick Wright plays the notes from the "Soon after dark, Emily plays" lyric from Syd's "See Emily Play."
Definitely a nice bit of goodbye.
Oldpink - New Castle, In
What can I add? Pink Floyd is the rock band greatest and SOYCD is one of their greatest. Without getting into the meanings of their lyrics, their musical performances are suburb!Pete - Houston, Tx
What else can I say about this masterpiece?
Probably Roger's finest lyrics, and Dave's opening solo especially is so beautiful that it will bring tears to your eyes, and I am not exaggerating.
Even now, after having listened to this scores of times over these years, this song still just GETS me.
Threatened by shadows at night/And exposed in the light
Doesn't that perfectly encapsulate the torment of Syd's madness?
Oldpink - New Castle, In
come on your target
for faraway in laughter
come on you stranger
you legend,you martyr
and shine!
too beautiful to describe; feel it deeper.
Pink - Kolkata, India
I want Shine On and Wish You Were Here played at my funeral, by my (well not my anymore but my buddy's) band.

Shine On!
Jeremy - Ventura, Ca
i guess the music and the people behind pink floyd are immortals... they are the best band to ever walk the planet.. people believing other are living an illusion.. i m crazy about them all but i believe gilmours has mastered the art of combining his mind, soul and music... And Mr. Waters just creates magic when he sits down with a paper and pen.. i am a music illiterate but one thing i know that you don necessarily need to know music to fall in with their creations.. one just needs to have a heart.. and shine on is just another one of their gifts tht they have showered upon us mere mortals.. there is nothing like catching the band live... Mr. Waters had a gig in India last year.. that was beautiful beyond words.. they played the dark side of the moon.. that was by far the biggest event in my life.. i pray to God to either have them play another concert here or to make me a millionaire so i can follow the band everywhere they play..Swati - Mumbai, India
Wow interesting debate happening from devout Floyd fans! Mitchell I have to agree with the comment just below, you may not believe in all the darkness "crap" but what do you think the likes of Jim Morrison/The Doors, Jimi Hendrix, Floyd, Zeppelin and other greats all have in common? They were balancing on the fence between life and death, 3 of those artists are now gone and their music was so deep and inspiring and touched many people on a deeper level. You can't deny that they weren't traveling in some way towards a higher knowledge in some way or another. Look at what their music is about, look at what those figures stood for and tell me what you think they did that was different to other artists.Kelly - London, United Kingdom
Mitchell from Redding - you're entitled to your opinion, you don't have to agree, but I was simply describing the spirituality of Floyd's music, which is hard to deny is the essence of most their stuff. Anthony from Everett touched on that when describing his condition, the visions etc.. Maybe my style of writing was too poetic or descriptive, but eccentric ones can't help it. It is hard to fit in with "mainstream" ways of thinking or talking. Clearly something Syd lived with. Whether it is drugs, or mental illness or being in touch spiritually that shows these visions is irrelevant. It's there and whilst it may at times be scary Anthony, it's a gift. Because you're not oblivious, you understand and see through the matrix. Some people shy away from it or find ways to deal with it, some thrive on it and try to go further - ie. Barrett, wanting to fly out further and reach for the secret. Probably still not making alot of sense to some of you, but doesn't matter - we all view art in our own light, this song speaks to me and shows me things, probably does for most people on this page, just in different ways. So don't diss other peoples' thoughts or opinions on the subject. Unless of course they are talking bad s--t about it =)Elysia - Hamilton, New Zealand
Aaron, Fletcher Memomorial Home is about Roger Water's obsession with war and his dad.Peter - Huddersfield, England
Definitely some of my all time favorite guitar solos in this song! Especially the third one! It makes me high!Bella - Pretoria, South Africa
Marsha from Inglis, FL, I am so jealous of you for having been alive and present in the most brilliant eras in musical history!Wish I could have gone to a real Floyd concert!!!Bella - Pretoria, South Africa
RIP Syd Barrett. I miss you too much!!!...
This song is one of my favorites songs from Pink Floyd..Yeah, this song is perfect =)
Florencia - Santiago, Chile
this song is amazing, it's got so much feeling to it, especailly in the guitar, this song wouldn't be as incredible without Gilmour, just as many other Floyd songs, along with Waters's lyrics, the Floyd were amazing, i wish they'd get back together, the live 8 wasn't enough, four songs! they should have been given at least 2 hours so that they could do songs like shine on you crazy diamond and on the turning away and us and them because they are by far better than any other musicain that played and desserve to have that recognition, i love them so muchDaferdaty - Leicester, England
I am 55 years old and have lived r&r from it's inception to present. I join with all of you who feel Pink Floyd is the ideal that all other bands strive for, but will never achieve.
Thank you, Floyd, for the great sounds.
Marsha - Inglis, Fl
anyways this song is pretty good and even though its like half an hour, it was nice for the other members to do something for syd.unfortunately, when syd left, so did his genius and pink floyd was left with millions of fans but no real charm to me...shine on you crazy diamond
Ozzy - Fresno, Ca
A minor point about sourcing: A Saucerful of Secrets by Nicholas Schaffner is called an autobiography in the song facts. It's actually a biography. An autobiography is written by the person or persons who lived the life. A biography is a book written about a person or persons by someone else.
Great song, btw. I love how the lyrics don't start on the first SOYCD until about 7 or so minutes into the song.
David - Youngstown, Oh
Wow. There aren't any words to properly describe this song. Some artists and songs have the ability to just make you smile- Roger "Syd" Barrett (may his sparkling soul rest happily) was one of those people. So are the others in the Floyd when they're not singing about, um, serious things. "Shine On" is very sad and sweet at the same time. But we all knew that already. =]Shelby - The Other Side , United States
ok the band didnt act notice that it was syd wen he walked in to the studio they just thought it was someone who worked ther i think it was either rick wright or david gilmour that eventually clocked that it was syd. and they fired him from the group amusingly enough by just not picking him up for a gig in late 69 and that was it he was out the band and all because of LSD shameDaniel - London, England
Gee Emma, you are so observant. I am sure that no one else had noticed that 'Shine on You crazy Diamond' was meant for SYD. 'Shine on' definitely is not a reference to you- because you must not be very bright. This is a good song, but it does have a long introduction. Many people may not have even heard this song in its entirely, due to it. Sure, Dave Gilmour's guitar work stands out in this song, but I also like the saxophone solo that accompanies it.Randy - Colerain Twp., Oh
Probably one of the greatest lead vocalists in history. Syd used LSD and went crazy.
RIP Syd...
Joel - Columbia, Sc
Anthony from Everett - best of luck coping with your illness. This song is awesome, and it's really touching and very sad. Mental illnesses are real tragedies. Everyone who's reading this - take care, people. Drugs are crazy stuff. Don't let it ruin your life, please.Zuzana - Bratislava, Europe
Wish You Were Here is a masterpiece and one of the finest albums ever released and this is the best song on the album(both parts)Perry - Detroit, Mi
Shine On You Crazy Diamond. Shine on, Syd Barrett, may you rest in peace.Jordan - Calgary, Canada
I believe 'Syd' (his real name is Roger Keith
Barrett) did suffer from a condition similar to
mine. I would not label it 'Schizophrenia' as
the doctors would, as they really have no clue
about its characteristics . . .
One symptom is receiving visions through the
eyes and through the mind's eye. This is
nothing to envy. It usually takes the form of
a spiritual environment, a non-physical one,
and oftentimes it is overwhelming or heavy
with sinister emotion, like a nightmare.
Also, people like us have one hell of a time
growing up, usually latching onto substances
(most commonly coffee and cigarettes) that
can include LSD. Syd's story was not only
using LSD every day, but having his room-
mates spiking his coffee with it unbeknownst
to his knowledge. Dave Gilmour would be shy
to accept a drink at his flat because he knew
about the spiking operation going on there.
The other things I can relate to that probably
are in common with him are feeling set apart
from others; feeling abandonment from others;
and afterwards feeling the need to 'shock'
society. I am one of the lucky ones who
survived the institution and lead a normal
After returning to his Cherry Hinton home,
he had no desire to be exposed to fans or
reporters, or even his old bandmates
(supposedly). He was an excellent painter,
and a carpenter (he made all his own furniture)
and he enjoyed bike riding and entertaining
the neighborhood kids.
But he was in the top 5 of the world's best
guitar legends, by virtue of talent.
Quote: "Please leave us here...
close our eyes to the octopus ride..."
Anthony - Everett, Wa
I am planning a very non-traditional wedding. I am planning on using the "very long intro" to SOYCD as my seating music AND processional music. Just as the bass line kicks in, the processional starts down the aisle. I am working with the DJ for a perfect fade before the lyrics start. Now how is that for a tribute to one of the greatest songs of all time?Rebecca - Redding, Ca
Im a Huge Pink Floyd fan! I love all there music(a little bit TOO much..hehehe)but after just listening to all there albums and rare songs they produced, i've loved Shine On You Crazy Diamond prts 1-9 for about 7 yrs now. I think everytime I listen to this song it reminds me of Syd cause he brought PF together to form Classic rock that people dont forget. But if no one has ever listen to Pink Floyd I recommend you to buy 3 albums (1)Wish You Were Here (2) Pink Floyd - The Wall (3)Dark Side of the moon FORSURE~Ritsa - Vancity, Canada
Syd contributed to Saucerful of secrets, just not as much as Piper at the Gates of Dawn. The album after Saucerful was when Syd left, Casper from NetherlandsCody - Clarendon Hills, Il
Simply the pennacle of the rock and roll era.Bob - Corpus Christi, Tx
Syd Barrett.......its a shame that he totally lost his mind.....R.I.P SYD We'll miss ya......:(Joseph - Union City, Nj
The concert version of this on the P*U*L*S*E DVD is mind-blowing. The band is at their best, and it includes a sort of music video from the ovular screen above.Bill - Erie, Pa
Gilmor's guitar work is all about tone. With so many guitar "gods" showing off speed and technique, none can match Gilmore's pure tone and expressiveness, and this is one of his great tonal works, perhaps due to the emotions connected to a work about Syd.

The difference between a madman and a genius is all a matter of perspective.
Jackie - Virginia Beach, Va
Syd Barret's death was sad. Yet Pink Floyd still did better without himAndy - Apex, Nc
I guess we can imagine that Syd is finally at peace now.

I guess we can hope.
Aylin - Montreal
I cried when I heard Syd died... I knew it would happen soon though. Next to Roger Waters, he is one of my favorite musicians of all time.Steve - Laconia, Nh
It's sad to hear that Syd has died. Unfortunately, I'm not surprised. I heard it a couple days ago on NPR.Stefanie - Rock Hill, Sc
In pace requiescat, Syd. Shine on, crazy diamond.Bill - Erie, Pa
Sad to hear that Syd has died. Listening to this song now, It's sad that one of the founders of insanity- and acid-inspired psychedelic music had died. I guess Syd never had an easy life; all the LSD and stardom turned him into a troubled man, gripped by insanity and trips. We'll never see another mind like Syd's.
RIP, you crazy diamond.
Ashley - Moncton, Canada
RIP Syd. Shine on...Shannon - Bainbridge Island, Wa
Uh... Syd Barrett is still alive. I'm 100% sure. He just lives somewhere in England, really secluded. He doesn't get out of the house muchAshley Jade - Cleveland, Ga
I think 'You reached for the secret to soon and you cried for the moon' was Syd doing LSD(the secret, which can make you very creative)and he did it to soon because they hadn't even realesed an album yet. and the 'you cried for the moon' being him going insane.Pat - Georgia, Al
Elysia from New Zealand, what the hell are you talking about?!? You're right, no other band comes close to surpassing Led Zep's ande Pink Floyd's greatness, but I disagree with all that darkness crap. Oh by the way, this is an amazing song, one of the 10 best of all time.Mitchell - Redding, Ca
syd is very much still alive. hes supposedly got diabetis, chronick stumach ulcers, hes really fat and not the same cute syd barrett from the 60's. nowadays he sports the shaved off eyebrows bald head look(he showed up and one of Pink Floyd recordings sessions of "wish you were here" w/ this look). hes also reportedly a skitzo. if you just go on google you can find interviews with david gilmour or Roger waters where they express their feelings about syd. also there is a 3 books that i know of that you can buy about Pink Floyd if you wanna knoew more. one of theme written by Nick mason the drummer, and one even writtern by Syd Barrett's sister Rosemary. CHECK IT OUT!Michelle - San Diego , Ca
SOYCD on Pulse (live album) is really goodAlex - Fort Mill, Sc
I've always assumed that "now there's a look in your eyes, like black holes in the sky" refers to the dilated pupils of someone tripping on acid i.e. Syd. Plus i reckon Dave Gilmours artful guitar work is more emotive than technical. But then trying to copy his notes i found that what we hear as 'simplicity' is understatement and precision - its hard to make your guitar as expressive and fluid as Dave's.Ian - Manchester, England
This is one of my all-time favorites, and I think it matters, because I am a complete layman, and I know as much about music as I know about rocket science. Thus, I am devoid of any possible intellectual pretention that a man knowledgable in music may have! I have tried to make all my friends listen to it, and most of them (unlike me, they are smart and wise people) get bored and often refer to this song as "that long song without vocals". to me, that is a good sign, because I think what Sarte said about humans -- "When people write a lot about you, they actually want to bury you" -- equally applies to music as well. We all wish at times that we were insane, and envy the people who, due to their meantal instability, are above and beyond human pain and suffering. Oh, how I envy Syd Barrett!Pinchas - La, Ca
First time I listen to it, it was too long and boring. The second time it was too short, it a great song/opera and its one of my favorites. Songs that are longer than 4 minutes are great like Stairway, kashmir, hotel california . . . .
I Like the guitar, the lyrics, and the assembly of music from shine on you. Nick's drumming is so underrated but it gives quite a good sound to the song. David's guitar is great as usual. It's not their best song, but is problably their greatest work together. A masterpiece of Music
Juan - Miami, Fl
im not saying it's bad thoughJoey - Hw, United States
brilliant. one of my favorites, im sure the only thing that's not awesome is the long introJoey - Hw, United States
Syd Barrett is suposed to still be living. this web site has more things about him and some 2005 pics of him http://www.sydbarrett.net/Nathaniel - Pittsburgh, Pa
Does anyone know where syd is or if he had died, because it is kind of like he just dropped off of the face of the earthBrian - Why?, Il
Wanna see something crazy? Shine on You crazy Diamond. It spells SYD. I'm not sure if it's just a coincidence because the song is about him as well.Emma - ...
great song. i think that wen the floyd lost syd, they lost him "physically" but never emocionally. He always gets their songs dedicated 2 him (brain damage, all of the record wish u were here and most of the wall)Floyd - Dallas, Tx
GREAT, GREAT, GREAT, AND GREAT!!!!!!!! this is my 2nd favorite song. The floyd rule. This is definentaly about Syd. i have heard different things that this song is about that are crazy. The lyrics tell u. it says "come on you painter, you piper, and shine." Syd was a painter before the floyd and the firt album was called "piper at the gates off dawn" so syd was then reffered 2 as the piper.Pinkfloyd - Abbey Road, United States
The Pinnacle of all Free-jam groove songs. It has a sick beat to it, as well as several wonderful guitar solos, and can get stuck in your head for hours, maybe even days. This is one of the few songs that I have no care for anything but the song. not the lyrics or the meaning, but just the song. When I play with a band in my town, to groove this well, with this much life and voice, is hard to do. And you cant deny that it is a sweet jam sesh, because it hase a very loose tempo and theme. If there is any song you should learn to play that you don't know yet, it's this one.Stephen - Steamboat, Co
Ok Tormod if you have read any decent amount about Syd, you must know that he truly is insane. There's a very good chance that he had latent mental problems (along the lines of schizophrenia) before he started dropping acid, and the amount he was taking (at some points pretty much daily) would have no doubt caused them to surface. He may have been a musical genius (almost definitely), but with his noe fragmented mind he's lost the ability to keep his train of thought together for long enough to actually create a complete song. The touch of madness in him was what made him "shine", but he "reached for the secret too soon" and was "blown on the steel breeze". The look in his eyes is described as being "like black holes in the sky" came from his empty, glazed stare. Plus, who would drop the lead singer/songwriter/guitarist who happened to be a genius who could often write a song off the top of his head from their band unless they knew he wouldn't ever come back? C'mon David, Roger, Rick, and Nick loved that guy. Why else would they agonize over trying to put Madcap Laughs together?Max - Austin, Tx
Syd Barret was/is not a nuthead.. "back in thoose days" his life was ruined by drugs but the man was (may still be) genious! Through listening to Pink Floyd and knowing so much about them as I do, I get kinda attached to Syd and get a really sad feeling when I here the songs which is about him (ofcourse mostly the wish you were here album) U can see it in their eyes! Syd never left the band! He is still a MAJOR part of it! SHINE ON! (that one was for Syd)Tormod - Orkanger
not that i'd use the phrase "nuts". although its not that far from what happened. and don't get me wrong, i love syd barrett. its just...true.Jeanette - Irvine, Ca
well sort of about syd. not completely.Jeanette - Irvine, Ca
a lot of people say it takes a while to get into SOYCD, but immeadiately liked it when my brother had no cds except wish you were here and animals in the car so he played them multiple times. it is so long but it never even comes close to getting old! great song, album, band, etc. and its sad and scary that syd went so insane. i always sorta relate the wall to syd like its his story. like he built a wall that drove him insane or something. anyway i think pink floyd is my favorite band of all time except for led zeppelin, but they are so different its easy to love them both. anyway shine on pink floyd! (and all their loyal fans i love you all)Jeanette - Irvine, Ca
this is simply great straight ,stoned or trippin but very spiritual ,syd was ill maybe due to drugs or goin too far for too long ,but if you are reading this wondering if u will ever get back ,by listening to this u already are u just dont know it,Matt - Telford, China
SOYCD parts 1-7 is the 2nd longest Pink Floyd song, It runs 17:50.Takashi - Tokyo, Japan
Hey Ash, LSD is responsible for my ravings, a beautiful experience. Give it a go, just don't go overboard and make sure you have some Pink Floyd, Tool and weed on hand...ha ha.
Shine On you Crazy Diamond = my favourite song of all time =)
Elysia - Hamilton, New Zealand
Hey Ashley from Canada. You spelled fascination right, but you misspelled exclamations and their. I'm sure you didn't meen to though. everything else was spelled right.Stefanie Magura - Rock Hill, Sc
I think the line: 'You reached for the secret to soon and you cried for the moon', can be explained in many different ways. One way to look at it is as a reference to 'A saucer full of secrets', which was the first album to appear after Syd left the band, and 'the Dark side of the Moon', which was the last album to appear before 'Wish you were here'.Casper - Veenenaal, Netherlands
COMMENT 1: Maybe I'm crazy, or maybe I've just gotten used to the live versions on "Pulse" and "Delicate Sound of Thunder" but I think the above "songfact" stating that "Waters sang lead" isn't quite right. Gilmour sings the verses, if you will, ("Remember when you were young...") and Waters sings the higher-pitched stanzas ("You were caught in the cross-fire..."). COMMENT 2: I see lots of love here for Pink Floyd from Durham, NC. Either some fan has logged in under 4 different names from Durham, NC, or else Durham has a high per-capita ratio of Floyd freaks, in which case I may need to move. :) COMMENT 3: Scott in Chelan, WA: very eloquently put, my friend. COMMENT 4: Elysia in New Zealand: I'd like to purchase some of whatever it is you are popping. COMMENT 5: Wish You Were Here = greatest album of all time; David Gilmour = greatest guitarist of all time; Pink Floyd = greatest band of all time. and I'm spent...Ash - Charleston, Wv
At the end of part two, (at around 12 mins 06 secs) it sounds like they play the first few notes of see emily play: "emily tries but misunderstands". Any1 else noticed that?Helen - Oxford, England
Many voices to be heard about a great tune by one of the greatest bands to ever pick up instruments. This one gives me goose bumps, and to hear it live on their "Division Bell" tour was just amazing!!Dee - Indianapolis, In
Although on tthe album Wish you wer ehere the song is split... on Pulse Gilmour made it into one whole 14 minute song. ITs also played on Delicate Sound Of Thunder.. but they only play part 1Jimmy Bean - Averdeen, Sd
This is one of the paintings/drawings I've done based on songs. Others that I've done include The Great Gig In The Sky, Breathe(reprise), and Someone's In The Wolf by Queens Of The Stone Age. I'm currently working on Comfortably Numb, and Echoes.Ashley - Moncton, Canada
In the world of Pink Floyd, the sun represents Syd when he was well, and the moon represents him in his later state. This song expresses the longing for him to shine again.

When Syd was young, he shone like the "sun". Later, he cried for the "moon". In Dark Side of the "Moon", we hear about the "lunatic" - an old term describing the insane as "moon struck". And sadly, the "sun" was eclipsed by the "moon".
Scott - Chelan, Wa
Pink Floyd and Zeppelin stand aside from the rest because they have travelled spiritually to the dark side; they have had a peek of what exists above our "reality" and have reached a zone that plays beautiful sounds through them. The music they bring us is a drop of heaven to show us a side of us we all know. This is the highest form of art and expression. Sadly Syd was too curious. You can call him mad, crazy or diagnose his psyche to a scientific term, but he simply wandered too far off the track, where the temptress on the dark side wants to take us..where the amazing music came from and he spoke from there to us. He 'reached for the secret too soon', so he was lost. Only death permits us to see the secret, musicians such as these dare to stay on that border between the two sides and create songs so deep and spiritual as Pink Floyd do.
But we can always acknowledge Syd's courage, yet mourn that he did not hear the call when to come back inside from that place beckoning us all.
True artists are humans too.
Elysia - Hamilton, New Zealand
Patrick (from NZ), give yourself an uppercut! Shine On's one of the best Songs ever written by the greatest band to walk the face of the earth. Gilmour is not by any account a boring player, his solos aren't stereotypically flashy all the time. Knowing when and when not to show off technically is a sign of a great musician. Shine on is most definately about Syd. Alot of The Floyd's music is about Syd; Wish you were here, Fletcher Memorial Home, Brain Damage and Shine On are all really bluntly referring to SydAaron - Muswellbrook, Australia
i love this song perfect :)Kelli - New Milford, Ct
If you watched the wall it is pink is based on syd barrett with his shaveyness and crazziness obviosly thoughKirk - Vancouver, Canada
Amazing tunes and lyrics,as a longtime fan it will follow me to my grave.Siggi - Stavanger, Norway
Geez, a lot of people use exclamtion marks in writing thier thoughts about this song. "Now theres a look in your eyes, like black holes in the sky" and "threatened by shadows at night, and exposed in the light" are like, the best lyrics ever. I seem to have a fascination with nothingness, outerspace, light and dark, and that you can't see sound. ...did I spell fascination right...?Ashley - Moncton, Canada
I can't believe that people think dave isn't a great guitarist, or that he is a boring guitarist! No one could put so much emotion in to those guitar solos. Especially on SOYCD!Stefanie Magura - Rock Hill, Sc
Man what a great song! The writing is great, and the guitar solos are the best! I don't play guitar, but dave Gilmour is my favorite guitarist! dave's amazing! Roger waters is amazing! Btw, the slide solo is the best! Rock on! SOYCD is my favorite pink Floyd song!Stefanie Magura - Rock Hill, Sc
Man what a great song! The writing is great, and the guitar solos are the best guitar solos! I don't play guitar, but dave Gilmour is my favorite guitarist! dave's amazing! Roger waters is amazing! Btw, the slide solo is the best! Rock on1Stefanie Magura - Rock Hill, Sc
<> He should've signed up with Phillip Glass.Nessie - Sapporo, Japan
Syd was more of a obstacle in the way of making PF the ultimate band they became for example "remember when you were you were young you shone like the sun, caught in the crossfire, wore out your welcome" and the lyric that makes me think about DSOTM and... "you reached for the secret to soon, you cried for the moon"Doug - San Diego, Ca
i challenge all the john petrucci fans who say gilmour is a boring player to put the same feeling and effort into this as he did. hopefully gilmour tour in 2006...C - No., England
Roger Waters said in an interview that Dark side of the Moon was mostly about Syd. When asked about it, in the same program, Dave Gilmour became agitated and basically said "leave it alone." He was a friend of Syd, and was recruited when Syd started becoming disfunctional. I got the feeling that he just would like the man to be left alone.Jan - Sterling Heights, Mi
"Shine on you crazy diamond" was the final line of my speech at graduation. *sniffle*Nader - Durham, Nc
Bits of trivia (but that's what we're here for)
1. When Syd appeared at the studios he even asked when he should put his guitar on, like he was still in the band. THe band said that had already been done, which now seems like a shame, because it would have been interesting to hear if and how Syd would have done it.
2. At http://www.sydbarrett.net/welcome.htm there is a picture of Syd from this very session.
Erik - Lund, Sweden
Hi There; I wonder if someone can help me...I once had an album that was pretty much female vocals and some good beats; now about 10 years old (at a guess). They had one track that had as part of it an instrumental that was the instrumental part of Shine on you Crazy Diamond (the first parts). Does anyone know the name of the band...?Patrick - Wellington, New Zealand
Pink Floyd is the absolute greatest band in the world, I'm sixteen but I'm probably the biggest Pink Floyd fan in existence, i know everything about them, i truly love pink floyd. They are uncomparable to any other band, ever. Not even Zeppelin (although F*ing brilliant, completely different). Never will Floyd die to me. I one day hope that Waters can make peace and do a reunion tour, or at least I can somehow meet Roger, he is my true hero, genius. Amazing, fantastic human being. Pink Floyd foreverAndrew - Toronto, Canada
This song was actually a congratulations for Syd. The Floyd expected The Madcap Laughs to fail, and instead it was a huge success. They decided to congratulate Syd by writing a song for him.

Some of the members were jealous of Syd, because no matter what he did, the people loved his music.

On stage once he had a breakdown and started untuning his guitar and picking wildly, and instead of getting agitate, the crowd cheered him on.

During one segment in this song, as a tribute to Syd's technique, Gilmour plays a slide with a Zippo lighter, just as Syd did in Interstellar Overdrive.
Deepphreeze - Irvine, Ca
Those 4 notes are probably the most instantly recognizable ever.
A# F G E
James - Bransgore, England
alright young floyd fans, some of dark side is infact about syd barret and so is shine on, when you become larger fans like me, listen to there early stuff and you'll syd references all over the place.Charlie - Thomaston, Ct
Obviously that didn't help, but it wasn't the only factor. I'm sure he had a predisposition to such an illness that already existed before he took a shed load of drugs. Same as with Brian Wilson (Beach Boys).Ben - Essex, England
Dark Side of the Moon is not about Syd Barrett! Only
this song is.
Kurt - Downers Grove, Il
But you dont disagree that it was the copeious amounts of ACID the eventually lead to his breakdown.Corey - Vancouver, Canada
Sunny's right, that's what I was going to say. It's bad journalism and pretty offensive to call him 'nuts'.Ben - Essex, England
Has anyone ever heard that Dark Side of the Moon was written for Syd? I just heard it from a friend and have no idea whether it was true or not, but when I listened to the album the theme seems to make sense. Try it and let me know.Blackdog - New Milford, Nj
I had listened to The Wall several times and a few Pink Floyd songs that came on the radio, and until 2001 I didn't really appriciate it. A friend of mine passed away of a drug over dose, and he knew that he was dying, he was at his father's home, so instead of calling 911, he recorded a message to his mother telling her all of his last wishes. One of them was to have SOYCD and Wish You Were Here played at his memorial service. I have since become obsessed with the beauty and wonder that is Pink Floyd. I think The Final Cut and Dark Side of the Moon tie for greatest album.Kevin - Houston, Tx
It's believed that Syd suffers from Disorganized Schizophrenia. It's very poor taste to label him nuts. He was amazing and would probably still be were it not for this disabling brain disease.Sunny - Tulsa, Ok
During the final mixing sessions of this song in June of 1975, Syd Barrett came into the control room, where the remaining members of Pink Floyd were listening to the finished recording of the album. This was the eve before Pink Floyd were going on a US tour. David Gilmour didn't recognize him at first. They hadn't seen him in years. Syd was fat, bald, had shaved eyebrows and was wearing a white trenchcoat with white shoes. When someone tried to break the ice by asking Syd how he had put on so much weight, he maniacally replied, "I've got a very large fridge in the kitchen, and I've been eating alot of pork chops! That was the last time any of the Pink Floyd members have seen him... - fact taken from the Pink Floyd autobiography, "A Saucerful of Secrets", by Nicholas SchaffnerDave - Marieta, Ga
The ending of the song is simply beautifulKelly - Los Angeles, Ca
My favorite song by my favorite band. The live version on Pulse is way better than the studio version, due in part to the fact that David Gilmour sings instead of Roger Waters. The video for Pulse also contains cool visuals during this song.Kurt - Downers Grove, Il
My favorite Pink Floyd song, probablly one of the greatest albums of all time. While they were recording this album Syd Barrett made an appearance.Brett - Watertown, Sd
This is my 2nd favorite song by what I consider to be the greatest band ever. I am a guitarist myself and David Gilmour is my biggest influence, not for his technique but for his creativity. Syd Barrett was a genius musician, who will always be remembered by all true Floyd fans as the inspiring artist that he was. Shine On.Corey - Dark Side Of The Moon, Other
it is indisputable that Pink Floyd is if not one the greatest band then one of the top three(i would also like to enlist Led Zep and the third one it's up to you!!)Athena - Athens, Greece
Did antone ever notice if you abbreviate Shine On You Crazy Diamond you get SOYCD. Then if you cut out the letters O and C it spells SYD like Syd Barret in which the song was written for. I have never heard anybody ever talk about this but I'm sure somebody must have noticed it.Bryan - Philadelphia, Pa
This song is incredible. When my mother played (SOYCD)for me as a child, I simply couldn't apreciate it. 18 years later, I cant say enough about it. As i listen to the lyrics, the feelings and memories of being a child tear at my heart and fool with my mind. Me and my friends all love Pink Floyd. On the beach under a moon lit night, ladies, candels and the ever present beet of Floyd...My friends and I are living proof that Pink Floyd will live on for ever!Anthony - Wantagh, Ny
Yea I have to agree with patrick, Floyd and Zepplin are right up thereJefferson - Nekoosa, Wi
A true master-piece, a work of art. More than just a song, everthing flows so seamlessly and sounds so perfect. Beautiful.Brian - Paoli, In
Best song in the world. Nothing else can describe the genius of this band. This was true music. Pink Floyd is by far the most creative band in the entire known world. No one beats them. it was an orchestra consisting of 4 people. no one else can do that and make it sound as pure and clear as they did. I love them.Ben Russell - Durham, Nc
great tuneNeil - Wyoming, Mi
I am the keyboardist/singer in his band. I also believe pink floyd is one of the greatest bands of all time. Many people believe daves solos where simple and masons beats where boring. They dont know what they are talking about. their playing made the music great and they had some of the greatest jam sessions in their songs if not the best. Masons drumming match perfect with the song and it was his style. waters was a genious and a powerful song wrighter. My role modle Wright, had made pink floyd the electronic sound they are and had the excelent and trippy organ parts which were pure genious. our bands music was totally inspired by pink floyd and they should never be forgoten.Lee - Durham, Nc
I think this is the best song ever written by the best band ever. Waters you are my hero. Gilmour I love you. Mason you are the man. Wright you made the sound we now know as Pink Floyd. I love you guys. Someday if my band is famous I hope to play with you guys. I am a bass player/singer/songwriter. Everything about Floyd is brilliant. Thankyou for giving us all something special to cherish and love forever. If you guys are reading this... I just wanted to say thankyou. Most sincerely and with deep appretiation for all you have accomplished. -PatrickPatrick - Durham, Nc
see more comments