Suggest a Songfact / Artistfact
Album: Brooklyn BridgeReleased: 1969Charted:
This song was written by Jimmy Webb
and originally recorded by The 5th Dimension on their 1968 Magic Garden
album. Like "MacArthur Park
" and "By the Time I Get to Phoenix
," Webb wrote the song about a love affair that he had with Linda Ronstadt's cousin, Susan Rondstadt. And yes, she married someone else in real life.
When Johnny Maestro (former lead singer of the Crests) put together an 11-piece band, his managers complained that it would be easier to sell the Brooklyn Bridge than to promote such a large ensemble. The name stuck.
After the group recorded two songs assigned to them by Buddha Records and were less than amused with the results, Maestro was rummaging through his LP collection when he spotted this song on The 5th Dimension's Magic Garden album.