One of the more interesting duets in musical history took place on September 11, 1977 during filming of Bing Crosby's
Merrie Olde Christmas special, where he planned to sing "The Little Drummer Boy" with David Bowie. The show was recorded in London, and had a "Christmas in England" theme. Bowie, who was 30 years old to Bing's 73, was convinced to appear after producers agreed to air his "
Heroes" video on the show, which Crosby introduced.
When Bowie got to the studio, he made it clear that he did not want to do the song, so the writers on the show whipped up a new arrangement with Bowie singing the words "Peace On Earth" and some additional lyrics as counterpoint to Crosby's vocals. The thought of pairing a crooner with a glam rocker proved to be more than a gimmick, with this unique version becoming a Christmas classic.
Bing Crosby died before the Christmas special aired, which drew a lot of attention to the program. The duet could have easily died right there as well, but bootleg copies circulated and it grew in popularity. Much to Bowie's disgust, it was eventually released officially by his label RCA in 1982 and made #3 in the UK. The move soured Bowie's already strained relationship with his record label and he left RCA soon afterwards. The song was further popularized by MTV, which launched in 1981 with very few videos in its library. In particular need of Christmas videos around the holidays, MTV played the Bing/Bowie clip for many Decembers, introducing it to a new generation.
In 2008 the BBC DJ Terry Wogan and former choirboy star Aled Jones recorded a new version of the revised "Peace on Earth/Little Drummer Boy" adaptation, for a charity compilation album released in aid of Children In Need. Issued as a single under the name Bandaged, it became a UK #3 hit for the duo.
In the second place, the harmony is much simpler. The carol is intended to be sung a cappella. While the sopranos and altos render the melody and linear harmony, the basses and tenors shift between G and D sung as a bare fifth followed by G's in an octave to imitate the sound of a drum. On the chord change, they simply sing a D followed by an octave higher D in the tenor line. There is no shift to the subdominant chord, it's just tonic and dominant, and the harmonies in the women's parts play against them. The men's parts shift rhythms for each verse. In the first verse, it's a simple "prum prum" on quarter notes; in the second, it's "prum pum pum" on a quarter followed by two eighths. In the third, it begins with a more urgent rhythm of "prum puppa pum puppa pum..." and when the boy starts to play triplets are added on the second and fourth beats with the word "puddley" before "pum," and as mentioned in the history above, there is a section where the basses and tenors do a complicated rhythm to replicate drumming before the final phrase, "then He smiled at me."
In my opinion, it was very wrong for Onorati and Simeone to take credit for the co-authorship of this song when all they did was change a few words and their rhythms and add a chord. K. K. Davis was responsible entirely for this song, except for its origins in Bohemia, which she noted.
nice and touching song. I really enjoy hearing this song.
Thanks!
In the '60s. I distinctly remember a beautiful, older recording of this song. It was almost the only version played by New York city radio stations. On one of it's last playings in the early '70, the radio guy, unusually, talked about the recording.
He lamented that no one was playing that "classic" version anymore because they wanted stereo. He identified the recording as being by The Vienna Boys Choir and being on an early 1930's 78 on a German label!
It _sounded_ that old, with a nice mellow ambiance. The singers were _boys_ and men with only a finger cymbal added. Unfortunately by the time I was able to own a tape recorder, no one played that record anymore! Knowledge of this recording seems to have disappeared! It is certainly NOT the "original" Simeone Chorale version, nor the earlier Trapp family recording. I can find no earlier recorded reference.
The _really_ strange thing is- this recording is older than the "first" 1941 publishing date of "The Carol Of The Drum" by Katherine K. Davis! (she is the sole "creator" by the way).
Does anyone have info on this recording? Does anyone know the fabled "Czech" original? I go through this every year and I _really_ want to get to the bottom of it.
Merry Xmas everyone
"i have no gifts to bring"
"come see the new born King".....i get a chill