“There's a bunch of us; Edwin McCain, and Hootie and the Blowfish, and Collective Soul, Indigo Girls, Matchbox Twenty, Better Than Ezra, and we all kind of came from this sort of southeastern fraternity of bands.” »read more
Songfacts®: You can leave comments about the song at the bottom of the page.
Comments (43):
Dude, I'm totally with you on this one. You've got this down. Like drugs at temp. fix, wine isn't nothing like water. You really find who your are deep down when you make your own choices and stop letting the wine choose for you.
with open arms and open eyes yeahh..." love it!
both are rad! the lyrics are also awesome!
(but they always are!) once had to use this song for speech class!
Also, I was always told and assumed this had deliberate references to masturbation. "I should be the one behind the wheel" "Whatever tomorrow brings, I'll be there" As in, even if your single or alone you have your own "needs" to meet. "will I choose water over wine,, hold my own and drive" As in the water is onanism vs the thrill of real intamacy.
"and hold my own and drive"
Either way, the song is mediocre. Incubus hasn't been good since their earlier works, IMHO
The references start from the beginning and continue all the way to the end:
*) "...vague, hainting mass appeal." - an obvious reference to Christian group think.
*) "...waiver my chance to be one of the Hive" - same thing. Now the lead singer is pondering just what happens if he chooses not to believe. Is there really a hell?
*)Water over wine - very obviously a repudiation of Christianity. Jesus changed water to wine. The singer chooses things before - or without - Jesus. Water over wine.
*)"It's driven me before and it...everyonve else gets around." He was raised in and around Christianity, as are many in the U.S. Now he is growing away from that.
The idea that this is about alcohol is superficial at best, and likely hamfisted in thinking. Incubus are more subtle than that - hard rock underpinnings notwithstanding.
- Bren, Perth, Australia"
That is called a metaphor. The water represents the rougher choice of controlling your own life, whereas wine represents the smooth ride of being driven by fear. It's basically choosing the rough over the smooth.
Great lyrics, great band.