This heartfelt ballad finds Darius Rucker asking someone to love him in spite of his faults. The song was written by Ross Copperman, Jon Nite and Shane McAnally. "I always tell people, the first time I heard [the Black Crowes'] 'She Talks To Angels
,' those lyrics did something to me. I probably requested that song eight times at different bars in Columbia, South Carolina, before going home, putting on Bonnie Raitt's Home Plate
, and trying to write 'She Talks To Angels" for Bonnie Raitt. 'Let Her Cry
' just poured out," Rucker said. "For me, 'If I Told You,' inspired me like 'Angels' as it's not a song I wrote, but as a songwriter I would not change a line as it moves me to want to not only sing along but also as a songwriter it inspires a new perspective."