Comments: 26

• (not So) Obvious Guy 2025 from La-la-land, CaWith so few women being 6'3" tall, the interpretation was that the "Island Girl" was a Jamaican transvestite prostitute, which was somewhat common to the NY party scene.
  Now, since Elton was still in the closet at the time, in his songs. he would tease with the alternate lifestyle. To wit:
  • All the Young Girls Love Alice
  • Philadelphia Freedom (Billie Jean King's team)
  • The Last Song
  • Swing for the Fences
  and others.
  
  Now, Island Girl is STILL one rockin' tune!
• Obvious Guy 2025 from La-la-land, CaRE: Fatdaddyjack
  "...rock and roll was a communist plot to undermine the morality of the youth..."
  
  WTF??? Haha! So laughable!
  What, are you having a latent flashback from a past acid trip, or have you been believing Jesse Kelly's more extreme rants?
  
  But, please continue to comment with more of your amusing observations!
• George from Vancouver CanadaKnow the lyrics before you tell a girl she reminds you of a certain song.
  
  My interpretation of what snippets i remembered led me to believe an Island (south Pacific, or Caribbean) Girl was pme out of her element away from the natural beauty of, say, Tahiti.
  
  Luckily I said nothing to the star$ server about the song!
• Fatdaddyjack from UsaThis is a song that shows the continuing Moral decline of rock and roll. As a means that allowed certain types of people associate with other certain types, rock and roll was a communist plot to undermine the morality of the youth in America back in the 50s (sorry Elvis fans). Today you reminders everywhere. In this song, the racket boss (pimp) represents Ed Sullivan and others like him that made money off of said exploitation. The 'island girl' is Elvis (and others like him) acting and living a persona that's not real. Like a prostitute, there is no happy home life despite the persona, see the prison that was Graceland for Elvis.
  In short: Beelzebub doing what he does best.
• Eizwaz from Planet EarthReality. Poverty. Enslaving others for your own financial benefit. And a loving kind soul wishing to take a prostitute away from it all.
• Jc from ColoradoThe song is a masterpiece, as per par for Taupin and John. Ragtime melded with Caribbean overtones. The lyrics are genius. "...But the cause is lost"; Very hard-hitting truth. Once the woman goes to the working side, she can no longer feel romance or nostalgic.
• Anonymous'This hit No. 1, as noted, but in hindsight, it's pretty weak, if not downright foolish.'
  This song, in my opinion, with its electric guitar and counterpoint piano is much stronger than the campy and ridiculous 'Grow Some Funk Of Your Own' (and anything Elton sang after he had his nodules cut off) where the Mexican is threatening to kill the dreamer and all he can think is: 'Oh, he was so macho.'
• Eab from Troy, OhThe lyrics actually are "He wants to take you, from the racket boss (aka pimp), he wants to save you, but the cause is lost."
• La Zalewski from Pittsburgh, PaMore unintelligible Elton words - "she wants to take you from a wrecking bop, she wants to save you from a soda schloss..."??
  
  Not sure what a soda schloss is/was. Anyway, not one of my favorite Elton tunes.
• No Spic Inglish from Wish I Was Back In The 70’s NycEnglish spoken in England. English slang spoken in U.S. in the continent of America
• Lora from TnShe’s a big ole girl standing 6 foot 3 sounds like a dude to me IJS lol
• Barrett from West Coast Of The U.s.adont listen to Cathy from omaha. I grew up in omaha, and most of the people there are deeply disturbed and weird people. Notice how she tries to pivot the conversation from rascism to feminism and sexism.
• Bartist from NeptuniaCathy from Omaha. What the hell? It's a song about a thought or experience, perception. The meaning of the song could only be described by Elton or Ber. This is art. I'm a feminist too. We have a long way to go if this offended you. Most art isn't first person. When you watch a movie do you think its something that really happened or the writer had an agenda and ill will. They are people with good intentions your own thoughts and experiences can make it seem evil.
• K. from NycThe song is about the "black boy" not the Jamaican girl. It is a recitation of his thoughts and his desire to save the girl from exploitation and degradation. He fails, and he is one more john who makes a mistake in thinking he can save her.
• Nina H from Nyc NyYou all got it wrong...just like "one more john who made the mistake...bang-bang!"
  'Island girl' was not about a 'girl' at all...it was about some of the prostitutes that hung out by the westside hwy back in the 70s - 80s nyc. Its very amusing. New York City as I knew it growing up.
• Gregpry Mckinney from Glendale Ca UsaCan you imagine anything this explosive and imaginative on the boards today? This track can barely contain itself. Truly Elton's most fabulous hit of all time.
• James from Greater Vancouver, BcRacist?.....ya.....if you're deeply "PC." But didn't we leave PC behind with the 80's fer Krist'sake? This is one damn fine funky song, the imagery as colorful as ever in Bernie's lyric, even lurid. But so was "Dirtly Little Girl" from "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road." I didn't hear any PC calls of "racism" on that release. FERGET ABOUT IT! It's just a fun song!
• Cathy from Omaha, NeAs a feminist, this song offends me. It's degrading to women. It's both sexist & racist. White men do not own the world. She's welcomed any place she wants to be; and she has more potential than just prostitution; if she was given the chance.
• Gerry from Houston, TxSounds strange, but this song makes me miss W.T. Grant/GRANTS/Grant City and Woolco stores.
• Rick from Belfast, MeThis song was at the top of the charts when I reported to my first Marine Corps duty station after boot camp....Camp Lejeune,N.C.....in Sept 1975.....was a monster hit.....
• Paul from Marysville, WaTo me, Island Girl is the last great Elton John single from his heyday. He's had many monster hits since-- but after Island Girl he had a huge dry spell. Except of course for "Don't Go breaking My Heart" which went to Number One. But to me, that wasn't a great song.
• Kevin from Reading , PaIn 1975 Elton could do virtually no wrong, but as the year wore on, the strain started to show. This hit No. 1, as noted, but in hindsight, it's pretty weak, if not downright foolish.
• Kent from Toronto, CanadaTo add to Patrick's comment about "Grow Some Funk Of Your Own" also placing in the US charts: as this was a double A-side single, "I Feel Like A Bullet (In The Gun Of Robert Ford)" being the other side, "Island Girl" might be considered only one of three hits from the album.
• Darrell from EugeneAccording to my girlfriend, this song is Elton's only racist-sounding single, and the title applies to her since she was born in Hawaii and lived there until she was 11 years old.
• Carlos from Brooklyn, NySong is about a tall Jamaican prostitute.
• Patrick from Wevelgem, BelgiumSorry to contradict, but the second single "Grow Some Funk of Your Own" made it to number 14 in the American Billboard Hot 100.

see more comments