Josh Turner reflects on this poignant, bittersweet song about a past relationship, wondering what life would be like had it worked out. "[It's] a story about a guy who, in his quiet moments and free time, is thinking back on a failed relationship and wondering, 'What if? What if I was still in that, I wonder if she thinks about me when she's in her quiet moment,'" the singer related to Taste of Country
. "I think anybody who's ever been through a failed relationship can relate to things in this song. It's just kind of a nostalgic kind of thing. I feel like fans can really get lost in it if they allow themselves to."