The Audibles finished the beat for "Come Around Me" just when Poo Bear was on his way out to a meeting. They played their track to him as he was leaving. "He liked the beat a lot and he literally wrote that song in 15-20 minutes," Jimmy Giannos of The Audibles recalled to Billboard
. "He was recording it and rushing out the door."
When Justin Bieber came in later, he added his parts to the bridge and completed the ending. "That was pretty crazy for me to watch," said Giannos.