In 1959, Frankie Avalon had a US #1 hit with the same title
. There were two other instances of different songs with identical titles reaching #1 on the Billboard
charts. "My Love
" was #1 for Petula Clark in 1966 and another "My Love" turned the trick for McCartney & Wings in 1973. Then "Best Of My Love" topped the charts for the Eagles in 1973 and a different song of the same title was #1 for The Emotions in 1977.
Rick - Calgary, Canada