This was written by Dewey "Spooner" Oldham and Dan Penn, whose other credits together include the hits "I'm Your Puppet" (a hit for James and Bobby Purify), "It Tears Me Up" (a hit for Percy Sledge) and "A Woman Left Lonely." In our interview with Spooner Oldham
, he told the story: "Dan Penn was producing The Box Tops, he had produced a #1 record called 'The Letter.' He recorded that in Memphis when he and I were both living there. So he calls me one day and says, 'Spooner, will you help me try to write a song for Alex (Chilton) and the Box Tops?' He says, 'People have sent me some songs, but I don't think any of them really fit. This record company's been after me about three weeks for a follow-up single.' And I said, 'Sure, I'll try to help write a song for you.' We got together in the studio one evening with our little notes of our five or ten best ideas or titles. We each pulled one out and they eventually ended up in the garbage.
The next morning, we were getting tired and decided to call it quits. So we locked the doors, turned out the lights in the studio, turned off the instruments. Went across the street to the little café - name was Porky's or something like that - and ordered breakfast. I remember I was putting my head on the table. There was nobody in there, I don't think, but us and the cook. And I tiredly put my head on the table, my arms under my head, just for a few seconds. Then I lifted my head up and looked at Dan, and because I felt sorry that he needed another record and we were no help to each other that evening, I said, 'Dan, I could just cry like a baby.' And he says, 'What did you say?' And I said it again. He says, 'I like that.' So unbeknownst to me, we had a song started. By the time we walked across the street back to the studio, we had the first verse written. When we got in, he turned on the lights and the recorder, and I turned on the Hammond organ. He got his guitar out, and we put on a quarter-inch 90-minute tape, and we finished the song, just recorded a demo.
The next day or two in the morning Alex Chilton came in. I was so tired and weary I didn't know what we had, if anything. I played the little tape demo to him and he smiled and reached out his hand, shook my hand, so I knew he liked it, anyway. And then we got in the studio and recorded it shortly, I think that day."