Will The Circle Be Unbroken?

Album: The Original And Great Carter Family (1935)


  • Sometimes titled "Can The Circle Be Unbroken," this song is based on a gospel hymn published in 1908 with words by Ada Habershon and music by Charles Gabriel - both very prolific writers of church music. This hymn was reworked by the Carter Family and released in 1935."

    Part country song, part spiritual, it describes a funeral. We see the hearse come to take the singer's mother away, and the slow procession to the grave site. Returning home, he feels a profound loss as he grieves with his siblings. Comfort comes from knowing she is with the Lord.
  • The original 10", 78 RPM single issued by the Carter Family was titled "Can The Circle Be Unbroken (Bye And Bye)" and was marked "Sacred singing with guitar and autoharp." The group was comprised at this time of A.P. Carter (vocals, guitar), his wife Sara Carter (vocals, autoharp), and her cousin Maybelle Carter (vocals, guitar). Maybelle became a Carter when she married A.P.'s brother, Ezra.
  • The Carter Family made significant changes to the lyrics, most notably in the chorus, where instead of singing: "By and by, by and by," they sing "By and by Lord by and by."

    On the Carter Family version, A.P. Carter took the songwriting credit, so subsequent versions recorded with these lyrics must pay royalties to his estate. The 1908 version is in the public domain, but sounds strange to many listeners who are now familiar with the Carter Family rendition and wonder why "Lord" is removed from the chorus. When the song was performed live on The Voice in 2013, the 1908 version was sung in an effort to avoid copyright issues, but viewers objected and expressed their frustrations on social media, demonstrating the perils of performing the original.
  • The 1908 hymn this song came from is far more broad and ambiguous in its story, opening with this stanza:

    There are loved ones in the glory
    Whose dear forms you often miss
    When you close your earthly story
    Will you join them in their bliss?

    The Carter Family made the song far more intimate, placing it specifically at a funeral and identifying the mother as the departed.
  • A litany of artists have recorded this song, including Ramblin Jack Elliott, Joan Baez, Asleep At The Wheel, Willie Nelson, Pentangle, The Neville Brothers and Jerry Jeff Walker.
  • For the Allman Brothers Band, this song symbolized their resilience as they overcame the deaths of founding members Duane Allman and Berry Oakley. The band performed it at Duane's funeral after he died in a motorcycle accident on October 29, 1971, and the song became part of their live set. Their version first appeared on Eat A Peach at the end of the live "Mountain Jam." The album was released a few months after Duane Allman's death and dedicated to him.

    Gregg Allman also included the song on his first solo album, Laid Back (1977).
  • The Carter Family was not the first to adapt and record the hymn. Carson Robison, Frank Luther and the McCravy Brothers all recorded it before, but none of these versions gained widespread appeal.
  • In 1972, Nitty Gritty Dirt Band released an album called Will the Circle be Unbroken that brought together many luminaries in the world of bluegrass and country, including Doc Watson, Roy Acuff and Earl Scruggs. The three-volume set contains 42 songs recorded live on a 2-track machine. On the song "Will The Circle Be Unbroken," Mother Maybelle Carter sings the first verse, followed by Jimmy Martin on the second and Acuff on the third and Carter again for the fourth.
  • In 2005, PBS aired a documentary about the Carter Family called The Carter Family: Will the Circle Be Unbroken.
  • Carl Perkins got permission from A.P. Carter to use this song's chorus on "Daddy Sang Bass," which he wrote for Johnny Cash. That song is about a family singing circle.
  • Speaking to Mojo magazine, blues harmonica maestro Charlie Musselwhite talked about the healing power of The Staple Singers' version of this song. Said Musselwhite, "I never get tired of it. At one point in Chicago I had TB, and I just laid there and played this album over and over. The music went all through me and I'm convinced it healed me."

Comments: 5

  • Jessica from UsaThis song is essentially the "Theme" to the video game Bioshock Infinite. In the Game, it's used as a religious Hymn and is sung quite a few times. Ironically, the place "In the Sky" here is not heaven, but the Floating city of Columbia, the setting of the game.
  • Budoshi from Sandnessjøen, NorwayThe Nitty Gritty Bands version with Johnny Cash, Roy Acuff, Ricky Skaggs, Emmylou Harris, Levon Helm And The Carter Family.... That's the best one
  • Ed from Lake City, Flall these versions are good, but no one does it like gregg allman. he put his own soul on this one
  • Erin from Portland, OrAllman Bros are nice, but please listen to the Carter Family and Johnny Cash versions. Probably THE perfect American song - certainly one of the best songs of all time, period.
  • Lee from Heath, OhThe song was written in 1907 by Charles H. Gabriel (music) and Ruth Ada Habershon (lyrics). It appeared in "Alexander's Gospel Songs, No. 2" (1910), and, most likely, in earlier forms as well.

    And I know of at least two recordings that predate the Carter Family's version--both from the late 1920s, on the Brunswick and Columbia labels, respectively. The Carters changed the words and made the verse and chorus melodies identical (they removed the half-cadence at the close of the verse, for example). Oddly enough, gospel and pop versions of "Circle" are just as likely to feature the original words as they are to contain the Carter verses. And they are just as likely to credit A.P. Carter as they are to cite Gabriel and Habershon.

    Gabriel also wrote the music (and, sometimes, the words) for "Send the Light," "Higher Ground," "Since Jesus Came Into My Heart," "My Saviour's Love," and "His Eye Is on the Sparrow." "Circle" and "Sparrow" are frequently mistaken for folk songs, of course.

    There's a 1936 "Will the Circle Be Unbroken" by James D. Vaughan which has nothing to do with the more famous tune. It appears to have been an attempt to avoid copyright payments to Homer Rodeheaver (who, I believe, owned the song at that point). I have it in a 1943 R.E. Winsett songbook.

    Of course, the Carter version of the song represents the ultimate ducking of royalty payments! I have no idea why they weren't sued.

see more comments

Modern A Cappella with Peder Karlsson of The Real GroupSong Writing

The leader of the Modern A Cappella movement talks about the genre.

Bob DaisleySongwriter Interviews

Bob was the bass player and lyricist for the first two Ozzy Osbourne albums. Here's how he wrote songs like "Crazy Train" and "Mr. Crowley" with Ozzy and Randy Rhoads.

Allen Toussaint - "Southern Nights"They're Playing My Song

A song he wrote and recorded from "sheer spiritual inspiration," Allen's didn't think "Southern Nights" had hit potential until Glen Campbell took it to #1 two years later.

Director Paul Rachman on "Hunger Strike," "Man in the Box," KissSong Writing

After cutting his teeth on hardcore punk videos, Paul defined the grunge look with his work on "Hunger Strike" and "Man in the Box."

Penny Ford of Snap!Songwriter Interviews

The original voice of Snap!, this story is filled with angry drag queens, video impersonators and Chaka Khan.

Chris Squire of YesSongwriter Interviews

One of the most dynamic bass player/songwriters of his time, Chris is the only member of Yes who has been with the band since they formed in 1968.