This was the first We Are Scientists song to make the charts. It first came to attention when the band played it on The Late Show With Dave Letterman
in December 2005, and was later featured on an episode of CSI New York
. Appearing on Letterman
was the band's first time on television, to Keith Murray's recollection.
He says that although the general impression was of "a deer in the headlights," they didn't actually feel terribly nervous. "I think we just didn't really know how to navigate it," he explains, "and how do I play it – not in the musical sense, but in the experiential sense. I think we were just like, 'Uh, well, okay, I guess we play a song now? Look at camera? Don't look at camera? I'm gonna look at the floor' kind of thing."
They were invited back to The Late Show
in July 2008. "The second time was much, much, much more comfortable," Keith says, "because we had spent four years playing on TV with somewhat ludicrous frequency. So, yeah, the second time was, I would say, delightful. The first time was almost paralytic."
Keith describes his Late Show
experience as a positive one. "They've been doing it for so long, and being a major network New York City TV show, it's incredibly unionized. So everything is very rigid, there are very specific time slots in which you will load in and set up, and do a certain number of rehearsals first for sound, then for camera. And then you do those rehearsals at about, I don't know, one or two in the afternoon. I think they shoot the show at 5 or something. You are kept sort of locked away in your dressing room away from the other guests, actually. And then they give you a five-minute warning, you come downstairs, the first time you've been in the studio. You're connected to the show by a TV in your dressing room that you essentially watch late night TV at five in the afternoon. And then you go down and play. But actually everybody at Letterman
is super, super nice. And their booking agent actually sent us a personal letter afterward thanking us for being there and stuff like that, which most of the shows don't do. They actually are pretty nice. Judging from their recent bookings, I think they're at least musically trying to lean toward a younger, cooler crowd these days. I don't think we met their booking agent, but it seems like they've got a pretty young, cool crew working on it these days." (read the full interview with Keith Murray