Tony from Auckland . NzClem Cattini played drums on the Kink Kontroversy sessions.
John from ChicagoIt's funny though with you tube you can watch all the old music shows. Shindig, American Bandstand, hullabaloo, and all the British shows. Every time the Kinks are on doing you really got me or all the day and all of the night, every time its time for the guitar solo the cameras pan to the dance floor. I've never actually seen him play the solo's. So I' a little suspect. If anyone know better I'd like to see it.
Barry from Sauquoit, NyOn July 23rd 1965, the Kinks performed "You Really Got Me" on the ABC-TV program 'Where The Action Is' (see next post below)... On the same 'Action' show they performed "Set Me Free", and at that time was at its highest peaked position, #23 (for 1 week), on Billboard's Hot Top 100 chart.
Barry from Sauquoit, NyOn January 20th 1965, the Kinks performed "You Really Got Me" on the ABC-TV program 'Shindig!'... Four months earlier on September 20th, 1964 it entered Billboard's Hot Top 100 chart; and on November 22nd, 1964 it peaked at #7 (for 3 weeks) and spent 15 weeks on the Top 100... And on September 10th, 1964 it reached #1 (for 2 weeks) on the United Kingdom's Singles chart... The group's next charted release, "All Day and All of the Night", also peaked at #7 on the Top 100 (they also performed it on the same 'Shindig!' show)... Their next released record, "Tired of Waiting for You", peaked at one position higher than the above two records, it reached #6 (for 2 weeks) on April 18th, 1965... R.I.P. Jimmy O'Neil (Shindig's host, 1940 - 2013).
Geoff from London, United KingdomProducer Shel Talmy confirms Jimmy Page played rhythm guitar on this song. See extensive August 2012 interview here http://findingzoso.blogspot.com/2012/08/interview-shel-talmy.html
Paul from Garrett, Ky, KyMusic lovers everywhere, if you cling to any doubt that Dave Davies stabbed and choked those first four strings of his Harmony Meteor or, later, Guild Starfire, just listen to the wonderful "I Need You." This song, very much in the style of the Kinks' first two, growling hits, was recorded sometime later and features the same guitar sound and a wonderful, almost out-of-control instrumental break that leaves no doubt that it is a product of the same tortured youth that played on the previous songs. I mean, it is ludicrous to suppose that Mr. Page was called back months later to do "I Need You." Seriously, give "I Need You" a good listen. It's wonderfully raw and full of the same almost obscene style that characterizes early Kinks. If it had been released instead of "You Really Got Me" as the Kinks' first "growly guitar song" the Kinks would be just as famous and important to rock music as they are today. Thanks for listening. Paul in old Kentucky.
Markshark from Denver, CoThe Jimmy Page/Dave Davies kontroversy is one of Rock's all-time great paradoxical myths, and will (hopefully) likely never be reconciled with any degree of certainty. My own preferred observations: A) Taking nothing away from Dave Davies, I NEVER heard anything else from him - neither recorded nor live - that came within spitting distance of this original primal solo. Can I picture in my imagination, Dave hysterically wailing away on his G string as Ray hollers inspiration, YES - a most gloriously entertaining scenario! B) Take a close listen and it is apparent there are several rhythm overdubs during this deliciously chaotic anthem; I definitely hear a high-strung guitar (Jimmy's twelve?) on there, as well as other supportive tracks; these are easily discernable as dedicated stereo tracks, so it would seem to be a well-calculated production of carefully-crafting studio artists. There is a LOT more happening on this recording than a casual pedal-to-the-metal listen would reveal. C) My preference is to subscribe to the belief there is a gentleman's code which dictates Dave get the credit for this solo, whether deserved or not (how could he not deserve it - his mother's knitting needles into the Little Green Amp were a demented stroke of absolute genius, without which there would not exist a most necessary link of the chain toward Hard Rock). I find it particularly refreshing in this age of vindictive retribution, that Dave/Jimmy have the good nature and common sense to let sleeping "dogs" lay; I think it's all far more interesting and enjoyable to be left guessing about what really went down on that historic track! The raw uncontrolled sound and musicianship of this record grants its rightful presence among the most essential productions of prototypical Hard Rock, if not THE prototype! Without this recording, Van Halen would not have gained the recognition it garnered from its cover of this tune at their particular point in destiny. BTW, the Van Halen cover IMHO succeeds in building upon/artfully translating a great rock classic; if you can't stand Van Halen's copy, then dig up some of Dave's more modern live renditions, he gives little away to Eddie's accomplished virtuosity!
Rahul from Chennai, India1964??????? wtf..i can't believe it..... this definitely has that hard rock feel that rock songs on the 80s n late 70s...whoa.... like somebody said here..this song is definitely way ahead of its time.....
Derek from Worcter, Mathis was the first song i learned to play on guitar
Duke from Colorado Springs, CoIt is a shame the Kinks did not talk to the ventures, as they were the first group to use the Fuzz sound in 1962.
In 1960, a Nashville session musician, Grady Martin, accidentally stumbled upon the fuzz sound during a recording session for Marty Robbins' "Don't Worry 'Bout Me", due to a faulty guitar amplifier. The fault was soon reproduced by an electronic circuit, which was first marketed as the Model FZ-1 under the "Fuzz Tone" brand name and gien to the Ventures In 1962. It would have save the kinks a lot of amplifiers not to mention stupidity.
Scott from Lewisburg , TnI hate Van Halen's version... I am a big fan of Van Halen but not when they or any band does a remake it just ruins it
Vic from Knoxville, TnIs it me, or do the original recordings of classic songs like this possess a sort of magic that just can't be recreated in subsequent sessions or covers?
Alan from Syracuse, NyAhh, back to the days when credits were very disputable. If Jimmy Page says he didn't play on "You Really Got Me", I'd be inclined to believe him. Regarding credits...Back in those days credits almost never appeared on the records. In fact, written records of credits were seldom kept. Many musicians were paid in cash and never credited. Quite often, a musician who did cut a track may rightly believe they are on the release, yet most of these musicians know their sound and can tell or sense if it really is them on the release. All studio players in dispute could have cut a track but that doesn't mean it was used for the release. Sometimes pieces of different players' tracks were seamlessly spliced into one through many areas of a song. In those days, tape was manually cut and spliced. Today, software does all that.
John from Dundee, United KingdomI remember seeing the Kinks live on TV(yes, we had loads of live performances on UK TV in the 1960's,Melody Maker poll shows,Student's Balls, Ready Steady GO etc.) and on that evidence, would doubt that Dave Davies was capable of playing these solos(You Really Got Me / All day and All of the Night"). I had only just heard of Jimmy Page in these days but always understood that he played the solos. He was only a couple of years older than Dave Davies but had an enormous amount of experience. He played on "Baby Please Don't Go" by Them (Van Morrison) and was rumoured to have also played the solo on "Hold Me" by PJ Proby as well as countless other sessions eg."As Tears Go By" (Marriane Faithful).
Lester from New York City, NyMott the Hoople does an instrumental version of "You Really Got Me" on their first album. Mick Ralphs handles the guitar work very nicely.
Street Strategist from Hong Kong, Hong Kong"You Really Got Me" is number 10 in the list called "Sounds at the Speed of Music: 50 Rock Anthems at 100 kph"
Jon from Tucson, AzThe Kinks' version of this song is much better than Van Halen's! I always hear the Van Halen version on the radio, unfortunately.
Caleb from Christchurch, New ZealandOf course he could, that person was just silly. Though it does seem amazing that they were so young. Anyway according to Ray's autobiography X-Ray, Jimmy Page played 12-string rhythm guitar on some of their songs but not this one. And it was "All Day And All Of The Night" that he laughed at Dave's solo, which Ray thought was very arrogant of him.
Anyway, this song invented hard rock.
Stefanie from Rock Hill, ScDepending on how early dave started playing the guitar, I think it's entirely possible he could have played the solo at 17 years old.
Paul from Sacramento, CaJimmy Page has always, ALWAYS, denied playing on this song. He played as a session musician during the album track recordings for the Kinks first album recorded a few weeks after You Really Got Me was released (August 1964), but not on this song. One of the most persistant urban myths in all of rock.
Rob from Vancouver, CanadaAs to whether or not Davies could do the solo at the young age of 17, Van Halen was 17 when he did his.
Rob from Vancouver, CanadaWas sung by 'Jimmy' in the movie Quadraphenia.
Johnny from Los Angeles, CaSo did George Harrison, David.
Johnny from Los Angeles, Cathis is way ahead of it's time.
Joey from Nowhere Land, CaI'm trying to decide if I like The Kinks better or Van Halen when it comes to playing this song.
Well, usually in my opinion, the original version is better, so I guess I like the Kinks version better
Stig from Southern Alberta, CanadaI once saw an interview with Ray Davies where he told the story of Jimmy Page coming in from another studio /after/ the song was already recorded and laughing at the guitar solo. Ray was quite irritated many years later that Jimmy Page would try to take credit for it.
Collin from Midland, TxI am pretty sure Jimmy Page played rythm guitar on this song... I'm not sure what websites I found that on, but it was on several. The Van Halen version is pretty awesome also.
Andy from Arlington, VaInducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1990.
Einar Kvaran from Dixon, NmI am checking out the discographies of drummers Graham and Cattini and there is a lot [too much, in my opinion] of overlap. I am looking for clairification, so pitch in if possible. Einar Dixon, NM, USA
David from Northampton, EnglandChris, Swansea - Why isn't it possible that Dave Davies played the amazing guitar solos at such a young age of 17? I myself started learning to play guitar at age 8 and it is totally feasable that Dave started early as well. Especially with such a talented older brother as Ray Davies being about!
Chris from Swansea, WalesJimmy Page played on all the early Kink's records, including their first LP. Dave Davies, who was only about 17 at the time, could never have played solos the quality of 'Beautiful Delilah' or 'You Really Got Me' for instance.
Nalo from Shawnee, KsFrom the Ray Davies Autobiography - II X-RAY"
"I had heard Bobby Graham playing on other records and was bowled over by his style & power, he added a tidiness and a dimension to our sound. On the session for 'You Really Got Me' when Dave played the opening chords, Bobby Graham forgot the complicated introduction he had planned, and just thumped one beat on the snare drum with as much power as he could muster, and for the next three minutes he was one of us. After the take Graham smiled and started to pack up his kit so that he would be out of the way when we did the vocals. He knew that we had done something special' OK where does that leave drummer Clem Cattini on lead tamborine??
Nalo from Shawnee, KsP.S. to my comments below...of the 1000 songs big Jim did session work on including at least 3 Kinks songs, Big Jim Sullivan also played on several Donovan song's including Hurdy Gurdy Man, Sunshine Superman.
Nalo from Shawnee, Kswho really played in the session? It is becoming a crowd. It is very likely Big Jim Sullivan did. He was a legondary session guitarist, and played on -You Realy Got Me Kinks 13/08/64 Pye, All Day & All Over the World Kinks 29/10/64 Pye, Tired fo Waiting For You Kinks 21/01/65 Pye. To verify Big Jim played, check out-- http://bigjimsullivan.com/History.html he played on at least 1000 songs for many folks and is still playing. Also, what about the drummer? Was it Bobby Graham on drums as stated above? according to Clem Cattini who is a legend in drumming terms, Clem was on drums. He has appeared on 45 number one hit singles in the UK including---6/ "You Really Got Me" The Kinks. To verify check http://www.coda-uk.co.uk/clem_cattini.htm#Hits. Clem also played on Donovan's Hurdy Gurdy man, also on some T-Rex songs such as, Get it On, (better know as Get it On Bang a Gong in the US), Telegram Sam, and HOT LOVE. Many session players never got credits that is certainly a fact.
Joel from Arlington, VaRay Davies (Born in 1944) was not 22, but 20 when You Really Got Me was recorded in September 1964.
Craig from Madison, WiThis song is everything a rock song should be.
Roberta from Lawrence, KsLooking at the Jimmy Page discography...he played on the session that produced the LP The Kinks, and definitely played guitar on "I'm A Lover Not a Fighter." He contributed guitar parts to several other songs on the LP, but no one is quite sure which ones.
Rae from Sydney, AustraliaI am not sure how true this is, but Jon Lord from Deep Purple supposedly did session work on Piano/organ/keyboard on 'You Really Got Me'... though this source mentioned that Jimmy Page did session work with the Kinks too...
Lee from London , EnglandBobby Graham was the top session drummer in the UK during the 60's.He is rumored to have played on 15000 tracks and over 100 hits.Turned down the chance to tour US with the Beatles when Ringo Starr got ill.Rerecorded this song with Ray Davies 4 years ago.
Jude from Db, CaRyan Starr covers this on "American Idol"