Donald Fagen

by Bruce Pollock

At the keyboards, Donald Fagen was the smoky voice and songwriting co-conspirator (with Walter Becker) on all of Steely Dan's classic hits, from "Reelin' In The Years" to "Rikki Don't Lose That Number" to "Peg" and "Deacon Blues" and "Hey Nineteen." Carving perverse lyrics into cryptic and sardonic story lines, wound around a sampling from the literature of pop-rock-jazz-blues melodic constructions, the Dan's output also included some of rock's most memorably ragged character portraits, among them Charlie Freak, Rose Darling, Kid Charlemagne, Pearl of the Quarter, and Dr. Wu. Charting the inevitable comedown from a decade of street theater, Fagen and Becker swung from the chandeliers while the roof was caving in.

Now removed from such turbulence, and approaching his songwriting midlife alone, Fagen contemplates the glittering, standard-strewn byways that led him to this juncture in a much more measured fashion. In the last 30 years, he had produced but four albums, including the 2012 release Sunken Condos. As befitting his reclusive reputation, Mr. Fagen agreed to this interview only if he could answer all questions in writing.
Songwriting Style and the Early Years

I don't think Walter and I were songwriters in the traditional sense, neither the Tin Pan Alley Broadway variety nor the "staffer" type of the fifties and sixties. An attentive listening to our early attempts at normal genre-writing will certainly bear me out. It soon became more interesting to exploit and subvert traditional elements of popular songwriting and to combine this material with the jazz-based music we had grown up with.

In college we were both intrigued by certain humorists of the late fifties and early sixties, such as John Barth, Joseph Heller, Kurt Vonnegut, Thomas Berger, Terry Southern and Bruce Jay Friedman (I've since cooled on a lot of these writers). Walter read a couple of novels by Thomas Pynchon.

In 1969, Fagen and Becker were part of the pop group Jay and the Americans. Kenny Vance, who was in the group, produced early demos for the duo and shopped them around without success. He told us: "Everybody thought it was too far out, or it was, 'Where's the hook?" And I would say, 'The whole thing is the hook.'"
We both thought the predicament in which popular music found itself in the middle sixties rather amusing too, and we tried to wring some humor out of the whole mess. We mixed TV style commercial arranging cliches with Mersey beats, assigned nasty sounding, heavily amplified guitars to play Ravel-like chords, etc. The fairly standardized rock instrumentation of the original group added to the schizy effect. We never tried to compete with the fine songwriters of the era (Goffin & King, Lennon & McCartney). We were after a theatrical effect, the friction produced by the mix of music and lyrics - the irony.

Work Habits

At this point I can't really remember who wrote this verse or that chorus, but the way it often worked out was like this: I would come up with a basic musical structure, perhaps a hook line and occasionally a story idea. Walter would listen to what I had and come up with some kind of narrative structure. We'd work on music and lyrics together, inventing characters, adding musical and verbal jokes, polishing the arrangements and smoking Turkish cigarettes. Of course, the musicians would kick in with arranging ideas, bass lines, etc. when we got into the studio. Working without Walter was shocking to begin with, but I got used to having somebody to bounce ideas off. It wasn't that difficult coming up with the music, because I basically used to come up with the musical material anyway. But the lyrics were quite difficult. I think I was lucky to be able to draw on my own background for some semi-autobiographical songs.

Lately I work mostly in the daytime, in a small sunny room. I own a few pieces of electronic gear, but I work at the piano, for the most part. I compose almost every day, usually five or six hours on the average. I also make time to play some standards and jazz tunes and maybe run some scales. I used to be a workaholic (what a terrible word that is) - up all night, running to the piano before breakfast, that sort of thing. Nowadays I sometimes stop to smell those proverbial roses. These days I listen to very little music. When I do, I play old jazz records, Ray Charles, Chicago blues, some French composers, and once in a while, with shutters drawn, I sneak a listen to my crackly copy of Highway 61 Revisited. A goal I have now is to one day write a really terrific song and hear it in a movie theater.

Studio Musicians

When Walter and I decided we weren't cut out to be leaders of a touring band, we started looking for a more mature (some might say slicker) sound. Our original players went their separate ways and studio players were just the ticket. Because the cost of rehearsal time with studio players was (and is) high, we began to prepare fairly detailed charts before going into the studio, sometimes with the help of one of the musicians on the date. The players would run down the tune a few times and then we'd start recording. With luck we'd get an early take. More often we'd do quite a few. Solos were usually overdubbed and judged on flow and originality; however, a player with a nice touch could get by easily on blues alone.

Larry Carlton played on quite a few of our records. He's a real virtuoso. In my opinion he can get around his instrument better than any studio guitarist. He's also quite a good blues player. He did the solos on "Kid Charlemagne." The middle solo he did in two takes and we used parts of both. The last solo was straight improvisation. Sometimes a player would come in and rip off a solo like that, other times, if they were playing something which we didn't think was stylistically consistent with the song, or if they were just having trouble getting any idea, we might suggest a stylistic or melodic idea to get them started.

What's it like playing a Steely Dan session? Check out our interview with Jay Graydon, where he talks about playing the guitar solo on "Peg."
Because most of our tunes' were written to be performed only by Steely Dan, they don't lend themselves very well to cover renditions. The lyrics are not the sort that would inspire singers to cover them. And most of the melodies are instrumental type lines, and not songs in the usual sense of the term. By that I mean that a real song, it seems to me, has a kind of melody which is, first of all, very easy to sing. It has a natural flow, usually in a stepwise motion, with consecutive notes, simple arpeggios, and so on. That's a quality a lot of the great songwriters had. You can sing the melody without any chordal background and it'll still sound good. The melody is not dependent on the harmony; it's just a really good melody. I think our songs were derived more instrumentally, more in the way - not to make a comparison in quality - Duke Ellington would write. I think his songs in fact don't work that well as songs. He wrote for the people in his band, the specific players. He wrote lines he thought they could play well. And although we weren't writing for instrumental performers - we were writing for my voice - I think our background, because it mostly comes out of arranging and jazz, made us lean toward melodies that had that kind of structure - they're more chordally situated.

When I hear the occasional cover I almost always experience what I've come to think of as the Bill Murray Effect - i.e., Buddy Greco doing "Born To Be Wild."

November 7, 2012
More Songwriter Interviews

Comments: 28

  • Boney Patella Senior from Idaho66 years old, and close to dead, I've always loved Steely Dan music. I was initially confused by the music fronted by the Brooklyn voice, thinking Donald Fagen's voice used a lot of studio fixing. Got to see him and Walter at the GORGE AT GEORGE in Washington with a stellar large band, and Fagen's live singing (despite brooklyn accent) was right on the money.Also went to a concert in boise (bad venue),(bad seating),(bad acoustics),(horrible snacks),(no pot smoking), left early due to not much fun. I've been a working musician for years, trying to steal this brillantacy, still wondering how Fagen comes up with this stuff.
  • Randall Billington from CaliforniaThanks everyone for sharing your comments and observations. On the topic of cover performances, I'd encourage everyone who hasn't yet had the chance to give a listen to Leonid and Friendsriends performance of My Old School (it's on YouTube).

    I almost feel heretical uttering while I'm about to say, but I honestly believe it's every bit as good if not better than the original recording,, done alive in a single take, and with such infectious enthusiasm that one can't help but feel like the performance is entirely intended as the ultimate tribute to the original composers and musicians. (And the story behind Leonid & Friends is both fascinating and endearing.)
  • Big Al from Atlanta, GeorgiaSome bands are too good and/or stylized to readily lend themselves to covering. Steely Dan, Yes and Chicago seldom are covered in night club settings. I know; lots of people have done Colour my World, and the post Terry Kath era ain't really Chicago, but for the most part, bands that aren't like every other band don't get much copy.
  • Travler from West-by-godThese guys were in a league of their own! Musicians (for lack of a better term) today can't comprehend what it takes to make MUSIC! Becker and Fagen were the best of "Both Worlds"...Architects&Builders! Alas...there will be no more..." Dirty Work"!...the maids been sent home early! And "Any Major Dude" could tell you....a Steely Dan fan would "Never" confuse them with the Doobie Bros!
  • Paul from Des PlainesThe Nightfly would have been a fine Steely Dan record. Donald seemed to take over after Aja.
  • Kang from OtherspaceBobby, "Only a Fool Would Say That" IS a Dan song. "What a Fool Believes" is a Doobie song....
  • Al Harris from Kansas CityNo, the cover by Ivy on "Only a Fool Would Say That" is good but no where near as good as the Dan's. Same for Howard Jones on IGY. Nobody does it like Donald.
  • Steely Dale from RiI think the Ivy version of Only a Fool is very are you talkin about? MOFOs.
  • Bobby from The BeachWait a minute..."Only a Fool Would Say That" is a Doobie song, not a Dan song...come on, people!
  • Midnite Cruiser from AnnandaleNothing beats the original Steely Dan versions, that goes without saying (even though I just said it)... that said, I enjoy Barrytown by Ben Folds, and I agree with Charlie Freak - "Only a Fool Would Say That" by Ivy is as good as it gets.
  • Droughtquake from Bay Area, CaI like both Tom Robinson's version of Rikki Don't Lose That Number and Howard Jones' cover of IGY. I like hearing different interpretations of songs. But that's just my personal opinion.
  • Charlie Freak from East St. LouisThe Dan is awesome, as are all of The Don's solo albums. One cover that doesn't have the Bill Murray effect... "Only a Fool Would Say That" by Ivy.
  • Stefan from From Brunswick, Germanyto cover a song only makes sense, if you support it to some new meaning, better atmosphere, different feeling....df songs are that perfect, who wants to try that impossible mission? I still remember a IGY *copy* from howard jones. that cover was one time played at our local radio station - followed by a dozen originals in the next weeks. who thinks to modifie beethoven or michelangelo works would be a good idea?
  • David from OrlandoWith all due respect to Steely Dan's music, the Donald Fagen tune I will always be fond of is his 1982 solo smash "I.G.Y (What A Beautiful World)" from the album "Nightfly". Having first discovered the song on my local smooth jazz radio station, I first became hooked on the musical styling itself, especially the horns. Later on, I did some research on the real I.G.Y. (International Geophysical Year) which ran for one and a half years from the middle of 1957 to the end of 1958 at the dawn of the space age. Though the real purpose of the IGY was to study the earth in general, many of the findings coupled with fascinating discoveries of the planet and beyond led to great optimism regarding the future. While things may have gotten much more complicated than many would have liked in real life evolution, the song is a prime example of the timeless optimism that continues to prevail over the course of history and is necessary for the human race to sustain itself. The song may sadly be overlooked by many, but I am one who may never let it go.
  • Erin from Jacksonville, FlCan't thank you enough for the interview. I really enjoyed the glimpse into DF's head and the behind the scenes look as well. SD/DF have always been my favorite band, never tire of anything they have done. Smart, funny, funky, jazzy; it's just the best. Love SC, can't get it out of my head. Was able to see them on their last tour, one of the highlights of my musical life. Can't thank you enough DF for all the memories and the happiness you have given me.
  • Mike Reese from Chicago, IlAJA. That album alone would make mny careers .. I listened to it for days on end, and never got tired of it. And bringing in Wayne Shorter to solo on it .. the cat showed what a solo is supposed to be in a song!
  • Gavin from Mummy's TummyI met Don and Walter on the occasion of Everything Must go release. It was one of the most affirmative experiences of my working life to meet the guys whose music was and remains the most listenable I know and find they were pretty much the people I had hoped they would be. At a point in the interview I asked them about Jeff Skunk Baxter's move into weapons intelligence right on cue - the audio evidence is on rocksbackpages website - a fleet of black hawk helicopters came hellishly close to the football pitch size window of the beach front Santa Monica apartment where we were sat , a ferocious aparition, rattling the glass in the frame . "Don't f--k with the Skunk," said Walter, also right on cue. Legends. Great interview too.
  • John WagmanA couple of years ago I was walking up Madison Avenue in Manhattan listening to my Steely Dan mix and I came upon Donald Fagen and Walter Becker standing by a car and talking. Aja was playing on my mix. I debated whether to go over to them and tell them I was listening to Aja and how much I loved them but didn't. Not doing that or buying more Apple stock in 1997 remain my two greatest regrets.
  • David from SacramentoI find it curious that Fagen thinks Steely Dan songs "don't lend themselves very well to cover renditions." Maybe he's referring to covers that include vocals, because there are a ton of instrumental covers of Dan songs, some of them terrifically done.

    Also, how did Sandy attend a Steely Dan concert "in Tampa in the 1980s?" As far as I know, Fagen and Becker originally stopped touring in the mid-70s, and did not resume until reuniting in the 1990s.
  • Desertdivine from CaI am so hooked on SC that I wake up with it in my head, go to bed the same. Donald is a true treasure of a composer and musician. I can listen to SD or DF morning to night and never tire of it. This interview was just so revealing about his process. Thanks so much for this interview.
  • Elliott from St. Louis, MoWalter & Donald, to me are the quintessential songwriters of the day drawing from numerous styles, creating a gumbo that is incredibly delicious. They have greatly influenced my songwriting and they have set the bar for generations to come.
  • Mr. X from Flagstaff, AzBecker and Fagen are musical geniuses.
  • Sandy from Enterprise, Flthe Steely Dan concert I attended in Tampa in the 1980s remains for me a transformative experience AND it was a lot of fun. I think my date and I sailed out of the concert venue on a cloud of rapture.
  • Chuck from Atchison, Ks.This guy gave us Deacon Blues...for that alone, we should be eternally grateful. One of the great compositions of the 1970's.
  • Jack from Mesa, Az"Fagen" that is haha! -- I had just read the comment above it screwed me up
  • Jack from Mesa, AzThis left me feeling like i got a brief glimpse into genius but not nearly enough! I thoroughly enjoyed this, thank you Mr. Fagan and Sonfacts.
  • Eric from Brisbane, AustraliaThe only composers that I can claim to have heard their complete works are Fagan & Becker. Since 1972, each new release has been anticipated, acquired and absorbed with endless admiration. Whether as collaborators or solo songwriters, imo they have never produced a bad (i.e. disappointing) number. The statement above by Donald Fagan is the most revealing "interview" I have read in terms of defining the art of Steely Dan. Where to next? Will he remain faithful to the popular song genre, or perhaps be tempted to extend the form and compose for jazz orchestra? Either way, his body of work will surely survive beside those of Gershwin, Ellington, Brubeck, etc. P.S. my 22 year old son is as big a fan as I am.
  • Cw from CaGreat idea doing it this way: written responses. Clearly he puts as much thought into his writing as he does into his music.
see more comments

Editor's Picks

Jimmy Webb

Jimmy WebbSongwriter Interviews

Webb talks about his classic songs "By the Time I Get to Phoenix," "Wichita Lineman" and "MacArthur Park."


SugarlandSongwriter Interviews

Meet the "sassy basket" with the biggest voice in country music.

The Girl in That Song

The Girl in That SongFact or Fiction

Billie Jean, Delilah, Sara, Laura and Sharona - do you know who the girls in the songs really are?


KissFact or Fiction

Kiss is the subject of many outlandish rumors - some of which happen to be true. See if you can spot the fakes.

Did They Really Sing In That Movie?

Did They Really Sing In That Movie?Fact or Fiction

Bradley Cooper, Michael J. Fox, Rami Malek, Reese Witherspoon, Gwyneth Paltrow and George Clooney: Which actors really sang in their movies?

Gary Brooker of Procol Harum

Gary Brooker of Procol HarumSongwriter Interviews

The lead singer and pianist for Procol Harum, Gary talks about finding the musical ideas to match the words.