Who Is He (And What Is He To You)

Album: Still Bill (1972)
Play Video

Songfacts®:

  • Withers wrote this song with Stan McKenney, who also wrote some songs for The Chi-Lites. The song finds the singer angry and accusatory, as he knows his girl has been cheating on him. Withers explained to Mojo in 2003: "Stan McKenney sent those lyrics to me in the mail. I've gotten a gazillion things in the mail and that's the only one I've ever done something with, because I could see it. If I don't see it, it doesn't occur to me, so I don't attempt to say it."

    Withers wasn't the only one who could "see it." Many listeners could relate to the song, and it has endured through many cover versions. A 1974 recording by the group Creative Source, who like Withers were signed to Sussex Records, went to #69 on the US pop charts and #21 R&B. In versions by The Three Degrees, Jean Knight and Gladys Knight & the Pips, the gender is changed, making the song "Who Is She (And What Is She To You)." Meshell Ndegeocello, who is bisexual, kept the original lyrics when she covered the song in 1996, and in 2009, Tower of Power recorded it for their album The Great American Soulbook. (interview with Bill Withers)
  • Withers' original version was used in the 1997 Quentin Tarantino movie Jackie Brown.

Comments

Be the first to comment...

Editor's Picks

Female Singers Of The 90s

Female Singers Of The 90sMusic Quiz

The ladies who ruled the '90s in this quiz.

Christmas Songs

Christmas SongsFact or Fiction

Rudolf, Bob Dylan and the Singing Dogs all show up in this Fact or Fiction for seasonal favorites.

Gentle Giant

Gentle GiantSongwriter Interviews

An interview with Ray and Derek Shulman of the progressive rock band Gentle Giant to discuss counterpoint, polyrhythms, and... Bon Jovi.

Rob Thomas of Matchbox Twenty

Rob Thomas of Matchbox TwentySongwriter Interviews

Rob Thomas on his Social Distance Sessions, co-starring with a camel, and his friendship with Carlos Santana.

Second Wind Songs

Second Wind SongsSong Writing

Some songs get a second life when they find a new audience through a movie, commercial, TV show, or even the Internet.

Dave Edmunds

Dave EdmundsSongwriter Interviews

A renowned guitarist and rock revivalist, Dave took "I Hear You Knocking" to the top of the UK charts and was the first to record Elvis Costello's "Girls Talk."