Gunderson co-wrote the song about a rebellious female lover who has, "a little bit of devil in those angel eyes", with Jeff Coplan and Eric Paslay. The song came about through a conversation between Gunderson and Paslay. "We were just sitting there," Paslay recalled to Taste of Country
. "I usually just show up and see what song finds us that day."
"Then we stumbled upon 'little bit of devil in her angel eyes,' he added. "We thought, 'That's pretty cool!' Then we got the melody rockin' on it."