Album: Monsoon (1997)

License This Song 

• It's not hard to reach back to the day
  Underneath an Iowa sun.
  Running to the tower of waterloo, looking
  For the sullivan train to come.
  His five boys would run to the top and
  Salute him as he went bye.
  First we'd wave hello.
  Then we'd wave goodbye.
  
  It's not hard to reach back to the days
  After the attack on Pearl.
  Overnight my buddies turned into men, run-
  Ning out of time for games and girls.
  The Sullivan boys were not overlooked
  Uncle Sam calling each by name.
  The very next day they left on a mystery
  Train.
  
  Say goodbye, bye, bye, Mrs. Sullivan
  Don't you cry, cry, cry, cry, cry.
  "We regret to inform you
  The Navy has taken your sons away."
  So put your blue star in the window.
  
  It's not hard to reach back to her smile,
  When she received the letter.
  The ltters, they sounded generally the
  Same it said: "If they coudn't
  Be home, at least they were together on a
  Mighty fighting battleship,
  Somewhere in the south pacific."
  The letters never got much more specific.
  
  Say goodbye, bye, bye, mrs sullivan
  Don't you cry, cry, cry, cry, cry.
  "We regret to infrom you
  The Navy is keeping your sons away."
  All five, five, five, five.
  So keep your blue star in the window.
  
  It's not hard to reach back to the day
  When the war finally came home.
  Uncle Sam will send you a telegram, so he
  Doesn't have to tell you over the phone.
  I heard she cracked up, when they found
  Out what the war had cost,
  And all five of her boys were lost.
  
  Say goodbye mrs sullivan
  Go ahead and cry.
  "We regret to inform you that all your sons
  Have passed away."
  All five!
  So change your blue star to gold. Lyrics licensed and provided by LyricFind

Comments: 10

• Natalie from Lorena, TxI see a lot of comments about the meaning of the song, but I don't see anything about how the music is truly made. The beginning riff with the guitar is just spot on with this lyric. I also love how they use the repetition, "Say goodbye, bye, bye, Mrs. Sullivan/And don't you cry, cry, cry." Using that repetition gave us the satisfaction of singing along with the song. Honestly, the music behind the lyrics and meanings is just as amazing.
  April 1, 2021
  Natalie, Age 15
• Chris Word from Phoenix Az@Scott from Kankakee, Saving Private Ryan is actually based on events that happened to the Niland brothers, as a result of what happened to the Sullivan brothers changes in the law were made, and so the Army thinking all but the youngest Niland had been killed, and ordered a unit to find him and bring him home. My middle daughter, a H.S. junior just got a history assignment for WW2, and she is going to do it on the Sullivan brothers, and include this song with her report. Oh btw you really should wiki the Niland brothers it's quite the amazing story.
• Cory from Schaller, IaThe policy the government made was the Sole Survivor policy. My dad says him my uncle werent allowed to be on the same ship when he was in the Navy.
• Randy from Flint, Miall the boys in the Sulliven familly ware drafted as for the changes the millitary made i dont know but i know thate they ware all drafted
• Scott from Kankakee , IlThe movie "Saving Private Ryan" is in fact somewhat based on the Sullivan Brothers. The govt. had enacted a policy preventing the loss of an entire family because of the Sullivans and as a result sent in a team to find Pvt. Ryan. I believe this is commented on at the begining of the film.
• Erica from Saude, IaThe government didn't just send Mrs. Sullivan a telegram. The family was told by three men from the Navy's drafting dept. Also the family recieved a letter from the president at that time.
• Mike from Charlton, MaThe Sullivans story had nothing to do with the movie "Saving Private Ryan". They weren't actaully drafted into the Navy, they enlisted on their own. They didn't serve on a battleship, but the light cruiser U.S.S. Juneau, which was destroyed on while protecting a convoy to resupply troops on Guadalcanal.
• Eric from Orlando, FlThe military changed their policy so that siblings would not be stationed on the same ship/plane to avoid a repeat of the Sullivan tragedy. This did serve as inspiration for Saving Private Ryan (the true story, not the song).
• Annie Ladner from Columbus, MsThis is actually based on a true story of five brothers stationed on the same ship in WWII. Their ship was attacked and all five died in 1942. A movie was made about them in 1944 called "The Fighting Sullivans." Now, this I'm not sure about, but I think after that incident it became military policy to avoid that kind of tragedy... and I assume that's where the plot of Private Ryan came from.
• Wilfred from Melbourne, AustraliaThis sounds a lot like the plot to the movie "Saving Private Ryan"... are the song, movie and actual event connected in some way?

More Songfacts:

O.P.P.Naughty by Nature

The Naughty by Nature hit "O.P.P." doesn't have any curse words, but many oversensitive radio stations played a "clean" version with the word "kitten" edited out, surely the first time that word was censured.

Take Me Out To The BallgameNora Bayes

The guys who wrote "Take Me Out To The Ballgame" had never been to a baseball game but knew it was a good song topic.

Let's Stay TogetherAl Green

Al Green's commitment classic "Let's Stay Together" launched Tina Turner's comeback when she covered the song in 1983.

If It Makes You HappySheryl Crow

"If It Makes You Happy" by Sheryl Crow is about the sour grapes some of her collaborators from her first album expressed to the media when they felt slighted.

Rocket QueenGuns N' Roses

The moans of pleasure in the Guns N' Roses song "Rocket Queen" are authentic.

We Are The WorldUSA for Africa

Lionel Richie hosted the American Music Awards the night he recorded "We Are The World."

Editor's Picks

90s MetalFact or Fiction

Test your metal - Priest, Maiden, and Beavis and Butt-head show up in this one.

Gary Brooker of Procol HarumSongwriter Interviews

The lead singer and pianist for Procol Harum, Gary talks about finding the musical ideas to match the words.

Richie Wise (Kiss producer, Dust)Songwriter Interviews

Richie talks about producing the first two Kiss albums, recording "Brother Louie," and the newfound appreciation of his rock band, Dust.

Dave EdmundsSongwriter Interviews

A renowned guitarist and rock revivalist, Dave took "I Hear You Knocking" to the top of the UK charts and was the first to record Elvis Costello's "Girls Talk."

Richard MarxSongwriter Interviews

Richard explains how Joe Walsh kickstarted his career, and why he chose Hazard, Nebraska for a hit.

Bands Named After Real People (Who Aren't In The Band)Song Writing

How a gym teacher, a janitor, and a junkie became part of some very famous band names.