Bobby Whitlock

by Carl Wiser

As Bobby points out, they didn't expect him to live very long. We're glad he did, as he's a vital part of rock history, with stories to tell about his time in Derek and the Dominos and playing on George Harrison's legendary solo album All Things Must Pass. The cast of characters in his story includes Eric Clapton, John Lennon and Phil Spector.
Bobby Whitlock and Coco Carmel. Photo: Todd V. WolfsonBobby Whitlock and Coco Carmel. Photo: Todd V. Wolfson
Carl Wiser (Songfacts): How did you end up in Derek and the Dominos?

Bobby Whitlock: I was with Delaney & Bonnie and them. I was the last one to leave that organization. Everybody else did (Joe Cocker's album) Mad Dogs & Englishmen. I stayed with them and helped them do a couple more albums. Then the pressure got to be too much and Steve Cropper suggested I go see Eric and see what he's doing. He actually bought my ticket to England. I called Eric and said, "Hey, what are you up to," and he said, "I'm just getting my hair cut." I said, "I need to get out of here, is it all right if I come visit?" He said, "Sure, come on over," so I was over there two days later.

I was just hanging with him, we got around to picking and singing, and the next thing I know, we decided to put a group together. He and I were writing, it just happened real natural for us because we already had a friendship developed through the Delaney & Bonnie thing. He went on the road with us. We already had a friendship going, so us sitting around writing, playing and singing was not uncommon. I was staying at his country house at Hurtwood Edge in Surrey.

I knew George. George went out for a couple of dates with us when we were on tour with Eric. George, Paul and them had broken up. I was friends with George when all this was happening. He was playing me the songs he wanted to do on his record. Eric's ex-wife, I used to go with her sister, so that's another way I was hooked up with George. I spent a lot of time out there at Friar Park. George plays me all this stuff. He wanted to do his first record after The Beatles - he never got to do his own stuff, just one song on each album. He wanted to know what Eric and I thought about putting a band together for his album. Eric and I were already talking about it, and we had already talked about having Jim Keltner come over and be in our band.

Keltner was the original drummer, and Carl Radle. They were out on tour, they were still doing Mad Dogs. It turns out Jim Gordon and Carl come storming in from the Mad Dogs & Englishmen thing. We started right in on the session. I made a call, I called Carl Radle and Jim Keltner. Keltner was on the road with Gabor Szabo, and Carl Radle was on the road with Leon [Russell] and them. I talked to Keltner, and Keltner was going to come over when he got finished, but Jim Gordon got finished with that Mad Dogs thing and he stormed right on over and was in on it right away. The availability was there for a drummer, and Jim Gordon seized the moment. Keltner said Jim Gordon's been taking some pretty important gigs from him in Derek and the Dominos and All Things Must Pass. He was there and the need was immediate, so he filled the slot.

The Dominos were formed during the recording of All Things Must Pass. Carl and Jim wound up coming out to Eric's at Hurtwood Edge and we stayed out there and rehearsed. That got to be too much, so we got the Domino flat in town on 33 Turlough Street. We got out of Eric's place and the three of us were in downtown London raising all manner of hell and unrest.

We toured all over England. We did a club tour, and no ticket was over a pound. It was all word of mouth. We played The Speakeasy in London and The Marquee Club, then we played some really funky places up in Nottingham and Plymouth and Bournemouth - we went all over Great Britain. Here we were, these so called "big rock stars," and we were playing these funky places that would hold like 200 people. Of course, people were jam packed and spilling out on the streets and stuff. It was pretty wild, it was a great time.

We did this one tour, we rode around in Eric's Mercedes. We were all crammed in one car. The second time we went out in Great Britain, we upscaled it: we played small concert venues. Our first concert venue was the Lyceum Ballroom, a concert for Dr. Spock, the baby doctor. It was a benefit for his foundation. That was our real first concert. Dave Mason was in on it - he was a Domino for a day. Then we went and did other venues that were like one step up - Royal Albert Hall and places like that. We went down to Miami, recorded the Layla album and went on tour in the United States. We preceded the record for the most part. All Things Must Pass came out, it was a big record - "My Sweet Lord" was #1. We were on the road in the United States, George was playing all over. We were all over the radio with our playing with George, and the album Layla, nobody could get it.

There were a few venues we went to play like in Philly or someplace, and it said "Eric Clapton and his band." Well, we were not going to play that gig until they changed that sign to "Derek and the Dominos." For the most part, nobody knew who Derek and the Dominos were. People who were in on the know did. It was a band. It was an equal effort and opportunity band. We all shared equally in everything. Eric was a band member. He couldn't go from being in our band to suddenly being the band. He wasn't ready at the time to step out in the forefront without having some fire behind him, something he was real comfortable with. Jim Gordon and Carl Radle and myself made a pretty formidable rhythm section.

When the Dominos toured, we did a couple things in Europe. We played in France and bits and pieces here and there. We did Great Britain a couple times, came and did the United States, went back and tried to record another record.

Eric had a big ego and so did Jim Gordon. Eric had an inferiority complex. Those things don't mix, especially when you put alcohol and drugs with them. We were doing those sort of things. We were all indulging in our own form of egotism. I wanted to do my own thing. The premise of Derek and the Dominos was that we could play together as a band and still do our own solo stuff. That didn't work. Everything just got out of hand with the drugs and all that, so eventually everyone just drifted after the initial blow up with Jim Gordon and Eric.

When the band broke up, he refused to play with Jim Gordon ever again. They had a falling out right in the middle of the session, so that was that. That was fine with me, because what we were recording was garbage. They have it out now as the jams and alternate Dominos stuff, the second album, but it's garbage. I've heard garage bands that sound better than us. You can really hear it on there, it's just a lot of ego with Eric and Jim. I didn't want to get in the middle of it - a great deal of the stuff I didn't even play on. It was like who could play the most and get the most complicated.

When that whole thing broke up, I decided, Shoot, here I've got everybody I've ever played with, I'm going to record my own record.

I wanted to play. I was used to playing. I wasn't used to sitting around looking at my picture on my own wall. That wasn't my idea of doing what we were supposed to be doing. I decided to do my own record, so I called Jerry Wexler and Tom Dowd and talked to them about doing a deal, and we did. I had done a deal with Atlantic with Jerry. They said, "Go on in and do it," so I asked everybody - I asked Jim, Carl, Klaus Voormann, George Harrison, Bobby Keys, Delaney and Bonnie, Eric - I asked everybody I'd ever done anything with to give me a hand with this thing, so my first record was really Derek and the Dominos.

Eric and I were a pretty formidable writing team.

Songfacts: Did you always tour as Derek and the Dominos?

Bobby: Always.

Songfacts: How'd you come up with the name.

Bobby: We didn't. We were going to call ourselves The Dynamics. That was the one we came up with since we couldn't think of a name. Our very first gig was Dr. Spock's Lyceum. Ashton, Gardner and Dyke opened it up for us. Tony Ashton, real funny guy, was going to introduce us, but we didn't have a name, so we said, "Well, we're The Dynamics." We used to call each other nicknames, and Eric was "Derek," so we said, "How about Derek and The Dynamics." He said, "That's fine" and went out on stage to introduce us. He said, "Ladies and gentlemen, Derek and the Dominos." My heart went to the floor, I couldn't believe it. I could see myself in a zoot suit - we'd be wearing one color suit and Eric would be wearing another. Where I grew up, if the name was The Dominos, you were going to be wearing matching suits. That was the first thing that flashed through my mind, but it stuck, and that was that. That was the first time we were ever called Derek and the Dominos, but always after that.

Songfacts: I'd like to talk about some of the songs you wrote for the Layla album. You're not credited on "Bell Bottom Blues," but you were part of it, weren't you?

Bobby: I was not credited. That's part of the ego thing. Had I been credited on "Bell Bottom Blues," that would have meant I had more songs on the Layla album than Eric. At that time he had a massive ego trip going.

In 2000, Eric played with me on a show. We did "Bell Bottom Blues" and a couple of other songs. We actually played with all the other bands that night. Giants is the DVD that's out of that show.

I didn't say anything to anyone about me having written "Bell Bottom Blues," I think it's just something everybody knows. They did an interview at the piano with Jools Holland and myself. He said, "How did you and Eric come about writing 'Bell Bottom Blues.'"

In front of like 50 million people, I told the story. I said, "The rest of it, you'll have to ask Eric," and the camera pans over to Eric and he's shaking his head like I'm absolutely right. Eric wasn't looking after his business back then. He had management to do that. He was playing. It was no business stuff - nobody was into publishing or that whole thing. It was more of an ego trip with that thing.

Songfacts: Was it you two in a room with guitars together?

Bobby: That's exactly right.

Songfacts: Tell me about "Keep On Growing"

Bobby: "Keep On Growing" was a jam. We opened up our shows with jams. We had one called "Airport Shuffle." It wasn't called "Keep On Growing," it was just a jam. We jammed in front of 50,000 people, we would open our shows by just jamming. Now there's bands that do nothing but that.

It was a jam we did during the sessions. They were going to can it because it was an instrumental. It always gave us something to loosen up with, it was a great instrumental. You take all the vocals off, and you've got a great instrumental. They were going to keep it off the record, and I said, "No man, you can't do that, this is too good." I said, "Give me 20 minutes," so they stopped what we were doing and chilled out and I took a pencil and paper, went out to the lobby at Criteria - the studio we recorded at in Miami - and wrote the melody and the lyrics. They just fell out of me. I went back in and sang it. They turned a tape on and I tried to sing it myself and it just didn't come off right. They loved the song and what I'd done to it, so I told Eric, "Why don't we do this like a Sam & Dave thing - you sing a line, I sing a line, we'll sing a line together." We did it like that and it worked out. We did it right on the spot. That particular song was fresh picked, straight off the vine. What you hear on the Layla album was the first performance.

Songfacts: What about "Anyday"?

Bobby: Just another song. All those songs were unrequited love songs.

Songfacts: So when Eric was writing "Layla," he was with her?

Bobby: Yeah. With her but not living with her.

Songfacts: Was it weird?

Bobby: No. George knew. It was nobody's business. They were adults making adult, life-altering decisions.

Songfacts: What was going on in the Layla sessions that made the music so incredible?

Bobby: When you let a horse run a race, it will run its finest race on its own. When you get some musicians and you get some creative people, you give them the opportunity to do what they're supposed to do, and they'll do just that. Given the right circumstances, they'll perform at their peak. They'll draw from the source.

These songs don't come out of your head. They're not something you sit down and figure out. They're things that flow through you - we were just instruments, just like the instruments in our laps. We were provided an opportunity to lock ourselves away and let the creative principle of the universe flow through us.

Songfacts: The song that closed the album was "Thorn Tree in the Garden." Tell me about that.

Bobby: The album was mixed and all. We went back to tag the piano on the end of "Layla." The whole thing was over and we were listening back, and Tom said, "We have room for one more song." Eric said, "Bobby, why don't you do 'Thorn Tree in the Garden.'" I said, "Sure."

Eric and Duane [Allman] and Jim and Carl and myself all got around one microphone. Tom Dowd came out and placed us just so - everybody was a certain distance in and out - and we did it just like that. I was sitting on a bar stool - Eric was to my left, Duane was directly across from me, Carl was to my right and Jim was between Duane and Eric with a little bell. Carl was playing a pedal bass, Duane was on dobro and Eric was playing acoustic guitar with a pick next to me. I was picking with my fingers. Tom Dowd, before he succumbed to leukemia, did an interview in Producer magazine where he said "Thorn Tree in the Garden" was "The perfect stereo recording."

I had a little dog and a cat. I was living at the plantation in the valley - you remember the shootout at the plantation in the Leon Russell song. I was living there with Indian Head Davis and Chuck Blackwell and Jimmy Constantine - there were about 13 of us in this house in Sherman Oaks in the valley. I had a little dog and a little cat. One guy told me to get rid of my dog and cat because there wasn't room. I took my cat out to Delaney's house in Hawthorn, and when I got back my little dog was gone. This one guy in the house had taken my dog and done away with it. That was my only friend - this was the first time I had been anywhere outside of Macon, Georgia or the Memphis area. All of this was new to me, and I have an animal thing. I wanted to punch him out, and I thought, No, you can't do that, so I went to my bedroom and sat down.

I was thinking about a snake in the grass and some other ideas and I thought, "He's the thorn tree in my garden." I had this beautiful garden built in my consciousness where I was safe and secure with my little dog and my cat, and there's this thorn tree - that would be the guy who had my little dog put away. I wrote the song and it just came out of me. I hadn't even put it on paper, and I went out of my bedroom and knocked on his door. I said, "Come here, I want to play you something." We sat down at the table in the kitchen and I played him that song. He said, "Wow, Bobby, that's beautiful." I said, "You're the thorn tree. There's going to come a day when I have the opportunity to record this song, and the whole world will know about it. You'll know what you did to me for the rest of your life." I didn't realize it was going to go on the end of one of the biggest-selling records of all time. That was the furthest thing from my mind.

It's all about love anyway. There is no love of this and not that. There's no measure of it. Whether it's a dog, your mother, dad, brother, sister, your companion, your horse or your neighbor, it is that one thing. It doesn't have a distinction. There's no barrier, it's just one thing that encompasses everything if you stop and think about it.

Songfacts: What do you remember about recording All Things Must Pass?

Bobby: There's a song called "Wah-Wah." I was the last one to show up at the session - I was running late and my car went down on me. It was getting started, I walked in and Phil Spector said, "Phase those drums! Phase those guitars!" He's standing there looking out like he's the captain of a ship, and he says, "Phase everything!" A guy had to operate this phase shifter by hand, his name was Eddie Albert, and he had to work it by twisting this knob to the left, to the right, to the left, to the right. You had to do it manually then.

He's saying, "Phase this, phase that," I come in, I'm late and Billy Preston's sitting down at the organ, Gary Brooker is on the piano, where's my spot? Everything was on the downbeat. I said, "I've got it, give me that little piano over there, I've got my part." I played everything that nobody was playing - I played on the upbeat. That's me on the electric piano playing the exact opposite.

That whole session was great. George Harrison, what a wonderful man. All the time that I ever knew him, which was from 1969 to his passing, he was a wonderful man. He included everyone on everything he did because there was enough for all.

We were recording on the same equipment The Beatles used when they did all their stuff - we did it at Abbey Road.

Songfacts: What songs struck you from those sessions?

Bobby: "Beware of Darkness" was the first time I ever played piano. They needed a piano player for that, and I decided that's what I'm going to do. That was my first recorded piano thing.

What many people don't know, the O'Hara-Smith singers, that's Eric Clapton and me. If you listen, you can hear Eric and me wailing away.

Songfacts: Phil Spector has this reputation as a maniac, but it sounds like back then he wasn't crazy all the time.

Bobby: No. He made a bad a call. He's just eccentric, he's real creative.

Songfacts: He wasn't horrible to work for?

Bobby: I agree with his work ethic. I concur with him 100 percent when it comes to being creative in the studio - put six guitars on it if you need it. Duane Allman told me some orchestras have over 100 pieces because it's necessary. I told him, "Man, you've got piano, organ, two guitars - why don't you get two or three more guitar players and a couple more keyboard players Duane?" He said, "I needed them, I would."

For it to sound like it needed to sound, he needed his wall of sound to get what he needed. If it wasn't for Phil Spector, forget about The Righteous Brothers. There probably wouldn't be a lot of us here from "You Lost That Lovin' Feelin'" - you know how many babies were made to that?

Songfacts: He got a bad rap for the Let It Be sessions.

Bobby: Well, that title speaks for itself. He shouldn't have tried to put his signature on that, it was a Beatles record. That should have been left by itself. That was a four-piece band, and the fifth member was George Martin. He's the one who orchestrated that. He was brilliant.

Everyone has a different style. Tom Dowd was different. Tom wanted only four hours of everyone's time. He did not care what you did, just give me four productive hours of your time.

Songfacts: Did you play on the piano at end of "Layla"?

Bobby: Yes. That's Jim Gordon and me. He's not a piano player. He plays so straight - everything is right on the money. They wanted me to give it some feel, so Jim recorded it, I recorded it, Tom Dowd mixed them together. It's two different tracks. Tom edited out what he wanted and mixed the two together.

Songfacts: Did you guys know it was going to be part of the song?

Bobby: No. I hated it. When we did the song, we didn't have a piano part in mind. Jim was playing it, and Eric said, "What about that - that's good." The single didn't have a piano part, but there was a guy at some college station that was playing the long, extended album version, and suddenly it took off - a year and a half after the band was broke up.

That album has never been advertised. The corporate entity made all this money, and they never had to spend a dime on the product. It advertised itself.

March 26, 2004

Further reading:
Our 2015 interview with Bobby and Coco
George Harrison on "My Sweet Lord" and Leaving the Catholic Church

More Songwriter Interviews

Comments: 16

  • Wayne from B. As much as I like Clapton/Radle/Whitlock/Gordon with Delaney & Bonnie, I felt a lack of discipline and direction undermined the potential of Derek & the Dominoes. Delaney was a hard task master and his musicians - he always had the best, including Allman, Harrison, Leon Russell etc. - delivered when in his sphere. But as Whitlock has indicated, Clapton was insecure, egotistical, emotionally torn and suffering from substance intoxication much of the time. And that, in my opinion is why 'Layla and Other Love Songs' is a real hit-and-miss album that fails to live up to its potential. That's not to suggest I think it's bad; it just isn't what it could be, and that is a fact borne our by the fact that the band struggled to come up with material, they lacked focus and they were abusing substances to the point where the attempt at the second album failed dramatically. Upon its release, the Layla album quickly faded from sight. Due largely due to the lack of serious promotion, the average record buyer had no idea who Derek & The Dominoes were. And possibly because Clapton fans felt the need for him to be a Bluesbreaker or a Cream guy all over again. Most of those folks missed the Blind Faith and 'Delaney & Bonnie - On Tour With Eric Clapton' albums, so they had the shock of going from the blistering live 'Crossroads' by Cream to the comparatively low key (but excellent) 'I Looked Away' and 'Bell Bottom Blues'. 'Layla' later becoming a hit single had as much to do with Duane Allman (by then a star with the Allman Bros.) adding that opening riff (supposedly inspired by Albert King) and giving it rock radio credibility. As for the album, well, even in retrospect it is nothing more than a rough hodge-podge of decent and mediocre tunes whose only real claim to fame is the names of the players making the music. Though this was a killer band on paper, minus the D&B horns and D&B at the mics they were, at least on the album, little more than a backing band with time in a studio. And they didn't put that to great use.
  • Greg from CanadaLayla is the definitive rock classic to me. What is so interesting about these landmark songs, is that they can bomb in the beginning. Look at how Stairway to Heaven was weakly received at first. Like Layla, it will forever be a landmark rock classic.
  • Penny G from Murfreesboro, TnBobby Whitlock was just as much a part of D
  • Joe from Houston, TxJust a fantastic insightful honest interview.
  • MikeI got my first layla in71 wore it out by73 got another,I uzed to listen to it and look at the photos.Ive never before or since felt so connected to music or musicians there was always a hint of saddness in me duanes ghost i guess.But what a line up ,this world wont see the likes of again.Thank u d&d
  • Fred Schlip from GeorgiaGeorge Harrison was a brilliant musician. Clapton and Duane are great and flashy, but it is harder to do what George did. His playing was lyrical.
    I also think Bobby doesn't get enough credit for the Layla album. I wonder why Eric did that?
  • Colin from CanadaBrilliant album, one of my fav's of all time. Wow, after all these years you finally get to understand the huge input of Bobby Whitlock. When I was listening to tha album initially in the 70's there was a tendancy to focus on Eric and Dwayne (it was the guitar hero era). Now I have a better understanding of the immense importance of both Bobby and Jim. What a great band! Never heard the "single" version of Layla just the album version. I never even knew it existed until now. Thx!
  • Ross from GalileeCould someone explain why the mix on the Layla album is so busy, distracting and ultimately muddy? The "ego" word appears a lot in this interview. Is that it?
  • Bob from Lyme, Conn.Really enjoyed the interview, which touched on so much without any grinding of gears. Learned something, and that's always a thrill. Thank you.
  • Bill N. from Driggs IdahoHappened upon this site because of the recent experience of a friendwho as involved in a busines deal that went sour fast because a greedy lawyer decided to steal everthing,,or try to..My friend sent the lawyer the email and song"Beware of Darkness " the lawyer didn't get it but I sure did.... The darkness is ubiquitous my friends ...Bless George forever...
  • Scotty P from Big Island Hawaiithank you and mahalo bobby whitlock. I've often wondered more about you. Eric was everywhere, of course, back in the day, but you and the other dominos were the best in the business, but no one would interview you. I always the Sam and Dave thing you did with vocals. You were brilliant; did Jimi Hendrix ever hear your cover of Little Wing? Best cover ever. I read EC bought Jimi a new lefty Strat, but the Master was dead before receiving it? I loved your voice and miss your presence even on keyboards. Did you also play on Harrison's What is Life? Tom Dowd once called Layla the national anthem because it went nowhere on the charts for over a year. Thanks for mentioning Duane. Finding news about him was also difficult when I was growing up, and he was also dead too soon. GOD BLESS and thanks for talking with us. What did you think of Jim's CODA from Layla used in movie goodfellas? pretty strong stuff backing all of those homicides, what?
  • Buzzy from N.y.very neat stuff! the whole interview shows the music biz. in 1970 lots of very talented people with poor management.
  • Mr. Gasoline from Redwood City, CaBobby Whitlock is a songwriter's songwriter - there are so very few, JJ Cale comes to mind, Writer's from THE BAND, One or two Niel Young songs and a Dylan or two - just raw channeling of passion - downright godly
  • Julio Morales from Methuen, Mass.Have to say that I love Derek and the dominos... but i just would like to see the first couple of bobby whitlock being release... it is a shame that such records are out of print... Please realese those albums...
  • AnonymousBrilliant interview....derek and the dominoes were a superb band...the music will never age cause there's purity in the music. The ego came later.
  • MickGreat interview, and wonderful to hear the songs while reading it. Thanks
see more comments

Editor's Picks

Divided Souls: Musical Alter Egos

Divided Souls: Musical Alter EgosSong Writing

Long before Eminem, Justin Bieber and Nicki Minaj created alternate personas, David Bowie, Bono, Joni Mitchell and even Hank Williams took on characters.

Steve Morse of Deep Purple

Steve Morse of Deep PurpleSongwriter Interviews

Deep Purple's guitarist since 1994, Steve talks about writing songs with the band and how he puts his own spin on "Smoke On The Water."

Rock Stars of Horror

Rock Stars of HorrorMusic Quiz

Rock Stars - especially those in the metal realm - are often enlisted for horror movies. See if you know can match the rocker to the role.

Chris Fehn of Slipknot

Chris Fehn of SlipknotSongwriter Interviews

A drummer for one of the most successful metal bands of the last decade, Chris talks about what it's like writing and performing with Slipknot. Metal-neck is a factor.

Fire On The Stage

Fire On The StageSong Writing

When you have a song called "Fire," it's tempting to set one - these guys did.

Rob Halford of Judas Priest

Rob Halford of Judas PriestSongwriter Interviews

Rob Halford dives into some of his Judas Priest lyrics, talking about his most personal songs and the message behind "You've Got Another Thing Comin'."