Who penned this sad love song with Claude Kelly (Kelly Clarkson's "My Life Would Suck Without You
"). She recalled to Billboard
magazine: "I had gone into the studio with Claude right after I had left LA - which is where my boyfriend lives - so I was a total wreck. I was missing him so much… I broke down in front of everyone who was in the studio… I was like, 'I love this person so much and it hurts because I can't be with him.' Claude was like, 'Well, write about it!'"