Chelsea Hotel #2 by Leonard Cohen

Album: New Skin For The Old Ceremony (1974)

License This Song

lyrics

artistfacts

songplace

Songfacts®:

The Chelsea Hotel in New York city is where Cohen lived when he wasn't at his home in Montreal or his cottage on the Greek Island of Hydra. He chose the Chelsea because he heard he would meet people with a similar artistic bent, which he did. When introducing this song in concert, he would often tell a story about meeting a famous singer in an elevator of the Chelsea, which led to the sexual encounter he describes in this song.

In Leonard's Greatest Hits (1997) album notes he says: "I wrote this for an American singer who died a while ago. She used to stay at the Chelsea, too. I began it at a bar in a Polynesian restaurant in Miami in 1971 and finished it in Asmara, Ethiopia just before the throne was overturned. Ron Cornelius helped me with a chord change in an earlier version."
Introducing this song in concert, Leonard Cohen sometimes admitted that he wrote it about a very brief affair he had with Janis Joplin in 1968, explaining that she came to the Chelsea Hotel looking for Kris Kristofferson, and when she and Cohen ended up in an elevator together, he told her he was Kristofferson. She knew he wasn't, but figured he would do on this particular evening. "We fell into each other's arms through some process of elimination," Cohen said.

Joplin left in the morning, and he saw her only a few times after. She eventually did find Kristofferson and recorded his song "Me And Bobby McGee," which became a #1 hit when it was released after her death.
Why is this song titled "Chelsea Hotel #2" instead of just "Chelsea Hotel"? Ron Cornelius, who was Leonard Cohen's band leader for four albums and is listed as a co-writer on the track, explained to Songfacts: "He [Cohen] claims that I helped him with a chord change in writing an earlier version of this song. The truth is that I co-wrote the song with him on an airplane (eight hours) from New York to Shannon, Ireland. The reason it has a #2 behind it is that he tried to cheat me out of my share by re-copyrighting it that way (he changed nothing) - it was just 'Chelsea Hotel.' Anyone can check out the writer credits by contacting BMI to get the truthful writer credits. I ran his band for a long time (worldwide), played on his records, and have nothing but honest input to look back on - Leonard can't say that!!!"

Cornelius is a guitarist who played on sessions with many artists, including Johnny Cash, Loudon Wainwright III and Bob Dylan. He worked with Cohen before branching out into production and music publishing.
After the death of Janis Joplin, Cohen came to regret linking her name with the song. In a 1994 BBC radio interview, he referred to it as "the sole indiscretion in my professional life." He added regarding his kiss and tell: "Looking back I'm sorry I did because there are some lines in it that are extremely intimate." >>>
Suggestion credit:
Shannon - Kathleen, GA
Lana Del Rey covered the song for a single release. Her vocals-and-acoustic guitar version was released on March 27, 2013, accompanied by a nostalgic music video, which sees her performing the track with a microphone in a dimly lit room.

Comments: 8

Bill from UsaI can't speak to who deserves writing credit for what but there was most certainly an earlier version of the song. Leading Cohen expert Allan Showalter explains here for those interested. https://bit.ly/3BxsMBC
James Breen from AustraliaThe song seems to be a kind of eulogy.
According to LC, he started to write it in 1971, a year after JJ's death. He's apologised for mentioning intimate details of their encounter, and for mentioning her name, but I can't see why; she was no longer around to feel 'shamed' (and I doubt if she would have been too worried anyway). Plus, she isn't mentioned by name in '#2', although (despite Ron Cornelius' version of events) there is apparently a longer earlier version of the song (where her name might be included).
I always found 'I don't think of you that often' a bit dismissive, but with age came the acceptance that LC, although ultimately as flawed as all true poets are, was not going to let political correctness get in the way of the truth.
Pjironed from Dublin, IrelandI saw a video of Lenny on stage before starting this song and he told of his meeting of Joplin. Which was basically:
"I was standing in the lift and as the door was closing somebody jumped in saying they were actually hoping it was Kris Kristofferson in the lift. I replied (in a deep voice) "Hello little lady""
I think it was the BBC "I'm Your Man" documentary

It is also the same hotel that Joni Mitchell san about in "Chelsea Morning" which the Clinton's named their daughter after
Michelle from Seattle, WaI think the last line in the song ('I don't think of you that often) is brilliant. It's not depressing, it's simply honest. Cohen quotes 'Janis' as saying that she normally goes for handsome men but for him, she'll make an exception. You can just hear that conversation ('we have to stand up for the HOMELY rock stars of the world!!! Unzip your pants!') echoing thru the halls of that seedy hotel. Limo idling out front. The song is nostalgic without being moribund, touching without being saccharine.
David from Houston, TxCraig, I agree with your assertion that Cohen blends hopelessness with cynicism, as is often the case with intuitive lyricists and poets such as he. But I caution against use of the word depressing. He're a telling quote from the equally talented Townes van Zandt when asked why his lyrics are depressing: "Well, many of the songs, they aren't sad, they're hopeless." I believe that great lyricists just as great historians excel in intuition. Above all else Cohen, despite his fluent use of allusion, is fundamentally honest in his descriptions of life and love. "Those were the reasons, that was New York...I need you, I don't need you" This seems to me an example of his honest assessment of human nature (at least his own) in the act of love: ever-changing with the environment and the wayward currents of the mind.
Kjell from Trondheim, NorwayStatement from Leonard Cohen, March 2006 (from www.leonardcohenforum.com):

Ron Cornelius and I had dinner the other night.
Twenty years since we saw each other last.
Our old friendship was still there.
His memory is better than mine.
From now on, let it be known
we wrote Chelsea Hotel together.
Kjell from Trondheim, NorwayRonald Dean Cornelius is indeed listed as co-writer of this song in the BMI database.
Craig from Dunedin, New ZealandI always find the last line "thats all i dont think of you that often" to be a very (dryly)humourous. I think that Cohen sounds more depressing than his lyrics suggest!

see more comments

More Songfacts:

SailAwolnation

"Sail" by Awolnation was the first hit to mention ADD (Attention Deficit Disorder) in the chorus ("Blame it on my ADD"). Lead singer Aaron Bruno put that line in because his parents and teachers often told him he had that condition, which explained his poor grades.

Step Inside LoveCilla Black

Paul McCartney's favorite song that he wrote for someone else is Cilla Black's 1968 UK Top 10 hit "Step Inside Love."

If I Ain't Got YouAlicia Keys

Alicia Keys wrote "If I Ain't Got You" just after she'd heard the news that Aaliyah had passed away. in a plane crash.

Invisible TouchGenesis

"Invisible Touch" was the first time a band member (Phil Collins) had a #1 Hot 100 hit with a group after scoring a #1 solo hit.

Born on the BayouCreedence Clearwater Revival

John Fogerty was not born on the bayou - he's from Berkeley, California. He got the idea for the song when CCR was on tour in Louisiana.

Groove Is in the HeartDeee-Lite

One of the last hits with a track made up almost entirely of uncleared samples is "Groove Is In The Heart" by Deee-Lite in 1990. Soon after, courts ruled that samples needed to be cleared.