Sour Girl

Album: No. 4 (1999)
Charted: 78
  • songfacts ®
  • Artistfacts ®
  • Lyrics
  • Scott Weiland wrote the lyric about his first wife, Janina Castaneda. They got married in 1994, just as Stone Temple Pilots were becoming one of the biggest bands in America. Weiland admitted that he put her through hell with his capricious behavior that stemmed from his addictions.

    When he wrote the song, the couple in the midst of a divorce, which was finalized in 2000. In this song, Weiland sings about how she will soon be free of him, "a happy girl the day that she left me." In his memoir, Weiland wrote, "She had finally rid her life of a man who had never been faithful."
  • In the line, "I pay the ransom note to stop it from steaming," the ransom note is Weiland's divorce settlement, which he said "took forever and cost me a fortune."
  • Sarah Michelle Gellar, who was a huge fan of the band, played the female lead in the video. At the time, Gellar was a rising star thanks to her TV series Buffy the Vampire Slayer and her movies Cruel Intentions and I Know What You Did Last Summer.
  • The trippy video was directed by David Slade, whose work includes episodes of Hannibal and the movie The Twilight Saga: Eclipse.

    The clip features little people in costumes that look like the Teletubbies, which were big at the time. The band claimed this was a coincidence, and that the creatures are based on a dream Weiland had.
  • Many listeners thought this song was about Scott Weiland's girlfriend at the time, Mary Forsberg, whom he would later marry.
  • This was the most successful single from the group's fourth album, No. 4. With a soft, innocent sound, "Sour Girl" was a departure from the grunge style STP was known for.

    The album was released at a tumultuous time for the band: Scott Weiland had released a solo album the previous year, and his bandmates had formed an offshoot called Talk Show. Weiland was in the throes of addiction, and shortly before the album was released, he was sentenced to jail time for violating his parole (he was convicted of heroin possession the previous year). This killed plans for a tour and made it impossible to support the album, which suffered in sales as a result.
  • After Jeff Gutt replaced the late Scott Weiland as Stone Temple vocalist, he felt there is one song that is "off limits" for him to sing out of respect for the band's original frontman. Speaking to Brad Copeland of Rock 100.5 The KATT's Rick & Brad Morning Show, Gutt said he had "a particular thing" about performing "Sour Girl" because it was written by Weiland as "a personal message."
Please sign in or register to post comments.

Comments: 26

  • James Gibbs from NycThis is one of my favorite songs, music videos from one of my favorite albums of all time. I always interpreted the song being about him taking responsibility for being a dick trying to make amends by letting her go while still saying you already been a sour before meeting me so it wasn't all me. Great 60s vibe. i was dissapointed by their next album as it was horrible and not written by Scott.
  • Jim from Long Beach, CaI love this song. Plus the video with Sarah Michelle-Geller is great. She looks great as the dark wicthy girl in the video..
  • Chip from Stratford, CtI was seeing a girl named Cheryl when this came out.It was an affair type thing. Awesome song. Chip
  • Justin from St. Louis, MoWow, i cant believe thats what its about. I never knew, and i always thought in my head when i listened to this song, what would she do if i followed her, cause i put her through hell as well.
  • Kermsit from Plainfield, IlI love No. 4 Its just like all the other albums to me...imean common Glide and Atlanta are one of my fav. STP hits
  • Liam from Windsor, CaNo.4 was a very underated album in my opinion; granted its not as grungy as stp's earlier stuff, but some beautiful songs were made for this album.
  • Kari from Tempe, AzOne of the most beautiful STP songs ever. I heard this song right after I lost my virginity lol
  • Adrian from Kingston, Canadawhats that guy talking about sayin this song wasnt liked, this songs sick, i dont think any STP fans were dissapointed by this amazing tune, every great rock band makes ballads hahaha
  • Robyn from Philadelphia, PaTrue fans know that an artist must grow & change. If not, both artist & fan will stay stuck in their immaturity. I love this song! 1 of their best. It brings tears 2 my eyes! I knew it was about Scott's marital woes, but 4 me it's about the day I leave my parents. & 4 those who put down addicts, I was like you until I fell in love w/ 1. You never know who God will make you fall in love with, in order 2 teach you a valuable life lesson. Remember this.
  • John from Pyeongtaek, Korea - SouthI enjoy listening to STP because they can change their style. They do not make the same music all the time. A quality rarely found in todays artists.
  • Vince from San Francisco, CaThis is a great song! If you listen to the beginning guitar part it really sounds like the guitar parts in Black Hole Sun by Soundgarden
  • Spog Zallagi from Blue Hill, MeI thought the song is great. It's one of my favs. But No.4 is my least favorite album.
  • Guilliermo from New York, NyYep! Getting dumped really blows.
  • Andy from Portland, MeIf you truly like STP you can enjoy each of their albums in different settings or moods. Critics or anyone else with an opinion give you their interpretation. Music is not hard science. There is no right answer. Listen to Spears if you truly like it. No.4 is great(in my opinion)!
  • Chris from Edmonton, Canadai love this song so much its the best stp song.
  • Yen from Colorful, CoThe "EX" this is written for is a lady named Janina Castaneda. I'm glad she got away from this druggie!
  • Eric from Fort Worth, TxNo. 4 was hailed and praised a lot more than it was ever condemned and for the few fans they lost with their break away from grunge (which they actually did with "Tiny Music") they gain new fans and brought a fresh sound to their older following. At the time of its release, Rock was in a downward spiral and there were very few bands pulling their weight. This album was hailed by many as one of the (if not the lone) saviors of modern Rock. For those that never picked it up because you thought that it was too "lite" based off of hearing just "Sour Girl", you couldn't be more wrong. By the way, "Sour Girl" wasn't the first single off of the album, "Heaven and Hot Rods" was and it wasn't a "soft" song in the least.
  • Tim from Wertewteg, AlI saw these guys during their heydey, and Weiland tipped his hat to Zep during the concert with a version of "Dancing Days," and owned STP's debt to them (DUH!) so Zep analogies are profoundly correct. Anyone can like what album strikes them as best.
  • Nathan from Memphis, TnThe Santa Cruz Mike is the one I am talking about. He's homoerotic.
  • Brittany from Richmond, KyI really love the stone's No. 4 album! I love the sourgirl song too! I think its great
  • Andrew from Vancouver, CanadaI agree with pete, this is actually a great album and is totally undreated
  • Mark from Charlotte, NcOff the topic but I just had to say this' After all the accusations of David Coverdale 'ripping off' Led Zeppelin in his group, Whitesnake, skeptics continued to raise their eyebrows when founding Zeppelin guitarist Jimmy Page united with Coverdale during the early '90s in the super group, Coverdale Page. Although the collaboration was a fleeting one, it did spawn an album (which unsurprisingly, was very Zep-derivative), and a smattering of live dates.
  • Pete from Providence, RiMost STP fans I know were actually very happy with No.4,It was alot heavier then their third album "Tiny Music..Songs from the vatican gift shop" which was pretty much a jazzy like experiment. Most critics even hailed No.4 as a more fitting album for what STP was known for, I mean "Down" is heavier than anything they ever did on any album. So Adrian..I DISAGREE (pulls away in car)
  • Mike from Mckinney, TxYeah, dont listen to that Mike, he makes the rest of us look bad. Im sure he is thinking of Dean Deleo. Dean actually looks pretty freaking close to Jim Morrison. To the compaison of Zeppelin, I would eat you if I could, youre an idiot and obviously not a music intillectual since that was a stupid thing to say. Please die.
  • Tessa from Ottawa, CanadaWhat picture did you see where he looked like Jim Morrison? I cant even think of 1 similarity between the 2, neyond the drug use.... You;re cracked.
  • Mike from Santa Cruz, CaSTP are as much Zeppelin clones as DAvid Coverdale is a Plant ripp-off. "Sex Type thing" sounds like "In the Light". "Interstate love song" sounds like "Travelling riverside blues" ( wich they stole from Robert Johnson. And Sour Girl sounds like spanish radio, it woul make more sense if he sung it in spanish. The last photos I saw of Scott Wieland, he looked like Jim Morrison, I'm waiting for STP's Wieland Hotel.
see more comments