I Gave My Love a Cherry

Album: Lullabies (1600)
Play Video


  • The song the world now recognizes as "The Riddle Song" was originally titled "I Gave My Love a Cherry." Like most traditional songs, both the author of the song and the date in which it was written are unknown. This song is a lullaby based on two English folk songs: "Child Ballad no. 1" (also known as "Riddles Wisely Expounded"), and "Child Ballad no. 46." In this lullaby, which was said to be written in the 15th century, a maiden says she is advised to unite with her lover.
  • Some of the many artists to record this song include Burl Ives on his debut album Okeh Presents the Wayfaring Stranger (1941), Joan Baez, Pete Seeger, Carly Simon, Doc Watson, Sam Cooke, Shelby Flint on her album Shelby Flint Sings Folk, and children's music singer and songwriter Nancy Cassidy for her album Kids' Songs Jubilee.
  • By the 20th century, rumors began to circulate that the song contains hidden messages. The most shocking of these was the rumor that the line "I gave my love a cherry that has no stone," was said to refer to a woman who has lost her virginity. The song's "cherry that has no stone" goes back to the 15th-century version's "the cherye with-outyn ony ston." Some have seen it as a reference to the hymen, and some have even tried to reconstruct an original bawdy version from which modern versions are supposedly bowdlerized. However, the relevant slang sense of "cherry" is not attested till the early 20th century. Equally shocking was the rumor that the line, "I gave my love a chicken that has no bone," was said to refer to pregnancy, as the "chicken that has no bone" referred to the baby inside the mother's womb. The other riddles in the original do not resemble the "reconstructions."
  • Despite the popularity of the title "The Riddle Song," it is merely one of a multitude of riddle songs; the format is common through folk music. The song was featured in the famous toga party scene in the movie Animal House, where actor John Belushi's character, Bluto, comes across a folk singer (portrayed by singer-songwriter Stephen Bishop, who is credited as "Charming Guy With Guitar") performing the song for a group of college girls. Bluto abruptly takes the singer's acoustic guitar out of his hands and smashes it violently, then hands a splintered piece of it back, saying "Sorry." Bishop, who went on to write the hit "Separate Lives," told us that he and Animal House musical director Kenny Vance came up with the idea for his wussy folk-singer character to perform "Cherry." Says Bishop, "It seemed like the right song to do in the scene." >>
    Suggestion credit:
    Annabelle - Eugene, OR, for all above

Comments: 2

  • Leroy from Nc"The Twelfth of Never" by Johhny Mathis (and later, a host of others) sounds like a rip off of this old song. I wonder if someone claimed credit for this old public domain tune and made money off of it.
  • Don Farkas from Los AngelesAt the ripening age of 67 years old, I was very surprised to find out the lyrics of "The Riddle Song," as most of the world has apparently known them, are actually very different in tone than the ones I had been taught as a kid in elementary school. The only version I had ever heard before was the one sung to us by our fifth grade teacher, Mrs. Mulkurn (sp?), on her autoharp. The first two verses that she sang, about giving her love a cherry without a stone, a chicken without a bone, a kitten with no sighin', and a baby with no cryin', were basically the same, but the last verse explained: "A cherry pie a'bakin', it has no stones. A chicken made for stewin', it has no bones. A kitten when it's sleepin', has no sighin'. But there should not be a baby, with no cryin'. It was a much sadder song, and not a lullaby at all.
see more comments

Editor's Picks

Dan Reed

Dan ReedSongwriter Interviews

Dan cracked the Top 40 with "Ritual," then went to India and spent 2 hours with the Dalai Lama.

Millie Jackson

Millie JacksonSongwriter Interviews

Outrageously gifted and just plain outrageous, Millie is an R&B and Rap innovator.

Tony Banks of Genesis

Tony Banks of GenesisSongwriter Interviews

Genesis' key-man re-examines his solo career and the early days of music video.


WeezerFact or Fiction

Did Rivers Cuomo grow up on a commune? Why did they name their albums after colors? See how well you know your Weezer in this Fact or Fiction.

Jesus Christ Superstar: Ted Neeley Tells the Inside Story

Jesus Christ Superstar: Ted Neeley Tells the Inside StorySong Writing

The in-depth discussion about the making of Jesus Christ Superstar with Ted Neeley, who played Jesus in the 1973 film.

Oliver Leiber

Oliver LeiberSongwriter Interviews

Long before she was judging contestants on American Idol, Oliver was producing Paula Abdul. Here's how he helped turn this unknown choreographer into a star.