Why

Album: Soup for One soundtrack (1982)
Charted: 10 74
Play Video

Songfacts®:

  • Carly Simon steered clear of disco, but she caught a groove on "Why," a song written and produced by the Chic hitmakers Nile Rodgers and Bernard Edwards. When Chic's sound fell out of favor at the end of the '70s, Rodgers and Edwards started working with other artists - the Chic brand was toxic to radio because it was disco, but Carly Simon was more than welcome on playlists.
  • Lyrically, the song finds Simon asking her ex why he treated her so badly. They clearly have a failure to communicate - all they hear when the other talks is "La-di-da-di-da," a line repeated four times to make up the chorus. This is a departure for Simon, who is an elegant wordsmith known for finding just the right phrase, but it's not out of character for Rodgers and Edwards, who would focus on the groove.
  • A very low-budget video was made for this song showing Carly Simon larking about New York City, where she dances on the sidewalk and accosts some strangers at a café. It's a rare look at Simon dancing, and shows why that was never part of her show.
  • Nile Rodgers and Bernard Edwards wrote "Why" for the 1982 comedy film Soup For One, for which they did the soundtrack. The film was a flop, but the soundtrack did a bit better.
  • In Simon's home country of America, "Why" stalled at #74, but it did far better in the UK, reaching #10. In the late '80s, club DJs in Europe revived the song and in 1989 it was re-released as a single in the UK, this time going to #56.
  • In 1990, the DJ CJ Mackintosh used the beat in a popular remix of A Tribe Called Quest's "Bonita Applebum."

Comments

Be the first to comment...

Editor's Picks

Narada Michael Walden - "Freeway of Love"

Narada Michael Walden - "Freeway of Love"They're Playing My Song

As a songwriter and producer, Narada had hits with Aretha Franklin, Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey and Starship. But what song does he feel had the greatest impact on his career?

Martyn Ware of Heaven 17

Martyn Ware of Heaven 17Songwriter Interviews

Martyn talks about producing Tina Turner, some Heaven 17 hits, and his work with the British Electric Foundation.

Steve Morse of Deep Purple

Steve Morse of Deep PurpleSongwriter Interviews

Deep Purple's guitarist since 1994, Steve talks about writing songs with the band and how he puts his own spin on "Smoke On The Water."

Rob Halford of Judas Priest

Rob Halford of Judas PriestSongwriter Interviews

Rob Halford dives into some of his Judas Priest lyrics, talking about his most personal songs and the message behind "You've Got Another Thing Comin'."

George Clinton

George ClintonSongwriter Interviews

When you free your mind, your ass may follow, but you have to make sure someone else doesn't program it while it's wide open.

Janis Ian: Married in London, but not in New York

Janis Ian: Married in London, but not in New YorkSong Writing

Can you be married in one country but not another? Only if you're part of a gay couple. One of the first famous singers to come out as a lesbian, Janis wrote a song about it.