All The Girls Love Alice

Album: Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (1973)

Songfacts®:

  • This is a look into the gay lifestyle of England through the eyes and lyrics of Bernie Taupin, Elton's songwriting partner. He made up the tragic story of a young lesbian who died in the streets.
  • This song marked the first time Elton sang about a gay character, although it had nothing to do with him personally. The first time he sung from the perspective of a gay man was in 1981 on his track "Elton's Song," which had lyrics by Tom Robinson - a gay man.
  • Elton didn't try to obscure the subject matter of this song, saying it was "about a young girl who gets seduced by the naughty ladies."
  • Many Album Oriented Rock (AOR) stations added this track to their playlists, as it fit the format's criteria of less-popular songs by famous artists. One theory posited by some radio folks, who had plenty of time to ponder this song over smoke breaks, was that it had something to do with Alice Cooper - perhaps it was based on the shock rocker's female fans. Cooper was an acquaintance of Elton, and Bernie Taupin would later write lyrics for Alice's 1978 album From the Inside. We haven't found any hard evidence that Cooper was an inspiration for this song, however.

Comments: 17

  • Bennitron from Wisconsin U.s.of AWell let me tell ya, GoodbyeY.brick was or is a brilliant buffet of cinematic genius. All the songs tell a distinct story. What grey seal was about I have to look up. But you listen to "untitled" the song called untitled.. It's astounding. And I've seen that movie too" is eerie, haunting, sends chills. All the young girls love Alice is very dark also. The beginning of song wt maybe Johnstone on guitar sounds sharp, scrappy, and sets the scene of the streets in a big scary city. B.Taupins descriptions of a sad, abused young girl in a whirlwind of big city dykes that use her and almost sounds judgemental of lesbianism. (Getting your kicks in another girls bed) well maybe Taupins had to make it sound harsh, because it was a harsh narrative. But he himself certainly wasn't judging, these two fellas Elton and Bernie are geniuses and were meant to be. I love you gentlemen. Thank you.
  • Classiceockman56 from 77590I saw Sir Elton John in 73 and '74 Quite the performer entertainer!! This is my favorite "Alice" song.
  • Seventhmist from 7th HeavenI always wondered if it was also a subtle dig at Alice Cooper, who was certainly loved by many young girls.
  • Tricia Green from Cincinnati, OhioI recently lost my beautiful daughter, Terri Leann, and she had a Mona leza smile , I use too sit in a room with my cousin Johnny , he would play this Album I loved this song and, I would wonder what happened to Alice? I just found out in the lyrics, I thought it was suicide as they say happens toy sweet baby girl, but it's not true, I still don't know the truth but when I here Tiny Dancer, (I still break down) it was her lulalby. Thank you Sir John.
  • Mellissa from Southern CaliforniaBernie and Elton were war babies of WWII or in America, Baby Boomers. When the men are away, the women will play. These were young women after all. An old expression is known as a "sewing circle," was a double entendre meaning on one hand women who gathered to sew and on the other hand but it was also a place for secret bisexual or lesbian sexual liaisons. This was particularly the case in times of war. Alice was the younger and hotter young girl who would service the wives of servicemen.
  • Tom from Los AngelesI dabbled a little in lyric writing some years ago, but I would have never come up with rhyming Soho and yo-yo. Gosh, that is funny. Hats off to Bernie
  • Cee from DetroitSong was inspired by Alice Cooper and his performances. As mentioned by Sir Elton John in "Super Duper Alice Cooper," an Alice Cooper documentary.
  • Chezchez from New York, NyYou gotta remember that in the early 70's this song was quite graphic compared to others in this era. Elton is a genius and so is Bernie none the less and are you listening to the music, THE MUSIC IS KICK ASS AWESOME for that time. - chezchez, Bronx, NY
  • Tom from Dallas, TxDidn't Bernie Taupin write almost all of the lyrics to Elton's songs the first 3 or 4 albums including all the lyrics on Goodbye Yellow Brick Road?
  • Cyberpope from Richmond, CanadaLots of arists singing, "Alice? Who the f--k is Alice?" (Smokie, Gompie, Dr. Hook, Eagles)
  • Pianowizzy from Denver, CoReply to Kevin: I don't this "Texan Love Song" is too bad.
  • Kevin from Reading , PaThe music is pretty driving, but this is a really unappealing song due to the lyrics and subject matter. I guess it's supposed to be shocking, but I think it's just awful. Taupin occasionally writes some really horrific lyrics, this being one. "Texan Love Song" from "Don't Shoot Me" comes quickly to mind as well.
  • Coffeegod from Brandon, MsYou mean this song isn't about a dancer from LA that Elton met who later had his child and disappeared into oblivion? *smirk*
  • Bill from Houston, TxBasically I heard the same thing years ago Stephanie Magura and that is that it was a tragic story of a lesbian. In the early 70's that life style was coming our of the closet then in the late 70's Queen blew the door frame off the wall........
  • Michael from Wallington, NjHey Leya, they ARE two dykes in the illustration for the song. Drag queens are cross dressing men.
  • Leya Qwest from Anchorage, AkIf you can get hold of the Goodbye Yellow Brick Road double record album cover, it opens up and inside there are illustrations that correspond with the respective lyrics of each tune. Alongside the lyrics of ATGLA there's a drawing of a pretty young girl, Alice, with two dyke-looking drag queens on each side of her. Guessing these two are but a few of the many lezzies who crave the attention of our girl as this song avows.
  • Stefanie Magura from Rock Hill, ScI always thought the song was the tragic story of a lesbian. I just wasn't sure though. i had never heard songs like that before.
see more comments

Editor's Picks

Yacht Rock QuizFact or Fiction

Christopher Cross with Deep Purple? Kenny Loggins in Caddyshack? A Fact or Fiction all about yacht rock and those who made it.

Bob DaisleySongwriter Interviews

Bob was the bass player and lyricist for the first two Ozzy Osbourne albums. Here's how he wrote songs like "Crazy Train" and "Mr. Crowley" with Ozzy and Randy Rhoads.

Waiting For The Break of Day: Three Classic Songs About All-NightersSong Writing

These Three famous songs actually describe how they were written - late into the evening.

Billy Joe ShaverSongwriter Interviews

The outlaw country icon talks about the spiritual element of his songwriting and his Bob Dylan mention.

The Evolution of "Ophelia"Song Writing

How four songs portray Shakespeare's character Ophelia.

Angelo Moore of FishboneSongwriter Interviews

Fishbone has always enjoyed much more acclaim than popularity - Angelo might know why.