Parting Gift

Album: Extraordinary Machine (2005)


  • Long before Taylor Swift turned her ex-boyfriends into song lyrics, Fiona Apple did it on this track, where she sends a message to all her ex-lovers. "You were always good for a rhyme," she sings, knowing she could at least count on some song material from the experience.
  • This is the only song from the Extraordinary Machine album that was not leaked onto the internet in 2005, months before it was officially issued. That's because the song was a late addition to the album.

    Extraordinary Machine was scheduled for release in 2003, but it got bogged down when the songs just didn't gel. Producing the album was Jon Brion, who did Fiona's previous album, When The Pawn... (1999). When it comes to writing songs and performing on her albums, Apple is intimately involved, but at the time she generally stayed out of the production process, trusting her crew to do the job. This worked for her first two albums, but on this one, it created a negative feedback loop where she would keep sending back the tracks for refinement, never happy with how they came out (the two exceptions: the title track and "Waltz (Better Than Fine)").

    After two years, Brion moved on and Mike Elizondo took over as producer, but they still couldn't finish the album. It finally came together when Brian Kehew, a producer who played on Fiona's previous album and was Brion's roommate, offered to start fresh on the unfinished tracks, recording them at his home studio with no record company intervention. Fiona took the deal, and after a month, they had the tracks done.

    This song was exceptional because it was a new one Fiona brought to the sessions, and was done very quickly. When Fiona came in with the song and offered to play it for the crew, Kehew instead set up microphones and had her record it, figuring they would at least get a version to work from that way. "She played it once and we recorded it and then we all said, 'That's it. The song's done. No more need for Take 2,'" Kehew said in our interview. "And it is on the record that way." (Here's Brian's full account of making Extraordinary Machine.)

Comments: 2

  • Brian from Los Angeles, CaThis song was recorded in one take, the first take we did of the song.
  • Theresa from Murfreesboro, TnJust Fiona and her piano - raw and honest song.
see more comments

Editor's Picks

Joe Elliott of Def Leppard

Joe Elliott of Def LeppardSongwriter Interviews

The Def Leppard frontman talks about their "lamentable" hit he never thought of as a single, and why he's juiced by his Mott The Hoople cover band.

Martin Page

Martin PageSongwriter Interviews

With Bernie Taupin, Martin co-wrote the #1 hits "We Built This City" and "These Dreams." After writing the Pretty Woman song for Go West, he had his own hit with "In the House of Stone and Light."

Subversive Songs Used To Sell

Subversive Songs Used To SellSong Writing

Songs about drugs, revolution and greed that have been used in commercials for sneakers, jeans, fast food, cruises and cars.

Soul Train Stories with Stephen McMillian

Soul Train Stories with Stephen McMillianSong Writing

A Soul Train dancer takes us through a day on the show, and explains what you had to do to get camera time.

Don Felder

Don FelderSongwriter Interviews

Don breaks down "Hotel California" and other songs he wrote as a member of the Eagles. Now we know where the "warm smell of colitas" came from.

Does Jimmy Page Worship The Devil? A Look at Satanism in Rock

Does Jimmy Page Worship The Devil? A Look at Satanism in RockSong Writing

We ring the Hell's Bells to see what songs and rockers are sincere in their Satanism, and how much of it is an act.