Extra, Extra

Album: Neil Young Archives Vol. 1 (1963—1972) (2009)
Play Video


  • Long before the internet, we often got our news from physical newspapers. Those newspapers were published every morning, but sometimes extraordinary events would necessitate a special edition published off-schedule and sold ASAP. Such events could be declarations of war, outbreaks of disease, or something similarly cataclysmic. When this happened, street vendors would shout, "Extra! Extra!" to notify passersby.

    The once-common "Extra! Extra!" phrase serves as this song's title because it tells the story of a vendor who sees a man and wonders "what made him this way." While there's no explanation of "what this way" means initially, the rest of the song makes clear that the way is "haggard and destroyed by life."

    The rest of the song consists of the old man telling the vendor his bitter story of betrayal and abandonment by friends and lovers alike. Each verse ends with the chorus, which is a variation of the words, "when it's born, it's warm, then it gathers." The song is a pessimistic account of a man done wrong by life, or at least a man who believes he's been done wrong by life. As in most such real-world testaments, the wronged is often blind to his or her own contribution to their ruination.

    The last verse is a bit confusing because it seems to flip their roles. "As I went on my way," Young sings, seemingly indicating he was the one passing by while the vendor remains in place. It could be a trippy poetic device to switch them around, but most likely it was just an oversight. This song was written early in Young's career and was never finalized, recorded only as a demo that wasn't released to the public for several decades.
  • Young wrote the song in 1965, the same period in which he produced "The Rent Is Always Due," "Don't Pity Me Babe," and "Nowadays Clancy Can't Even Sing." The common thread running through all of these songs is a deep pessimism and world-weariness that doesn't seem to fit Young's then-20 years. There's a reason for this.

    At that period in his life Young was dealing with a lot of rejection and failure. It was a sad, wandering time that followed the breakup of his Toronto band named 4 To Go. The group started with high hopes but never even played a show. They practiced and tried to find an in, but the Toronto music scene was "locked up" as Young told John Einarson in Don't Be Denied. He'd been going hard, trying to make it as a musician for some time, and the failure hurt. It's easy to imagine him projecting himself into that disillusioned old man lecturing the paper vendor about life's futility.
  • Young recorded the song as a demo for Elektra in New York City on December 15, 1965. Peter K. Siegel coproduced it with him. Young finally released the song on the Neil Young Archives Vol. 1 (1963—1972) in 2009.
  • In Don't Be Denied, Einarson also notes that this was the period when Young was starting to play around with the kind of lyrics he admired from Bob Dylan, who at that time was six albums deep into his career, including the seismic Bringing It All Back Home and Highway 61 Revisited.


Be the first to comment...

Editor's Picks

Gentle Giant

Gentle GiantSongwriter Interviews

An interview with Ray and Derek Shulman of the progressive rock band Gentle Giant to discuss counterpoint, polyrhythms, and... Bon Jovi.

Laura Nyro

Laura NyroSongwriting Legends

Laura Nyro talks about her complex, emotionally rich songwriting and how she supports women's culture through her art.

Rick Springfield

Rick SpringfieldSongwriter Interviews

Rick has a surprising dark side, a strong feminine side and, in a certain TV show, a naked backside. But he still hasn't found Jessie's Girl.

Timothy B. Schmit of the Eagles

Timothy B. Schmit of the EaglesSongwriter Interviews

Did this Eagle come up with the term "Parrothead"? And what is it like playing "Hotel California" for the gazillionth time?

Who Wrote That Song?

Who Wrote That Song?Music Quiz

Do you know who wrote Patti Smith's biggest hit? How about the Grease theme song? See if you can match the song to the writer.


AdeleFact or Fiction

Despite her reticent personality, Adele's life and music are filled with intrigue. See if you can spot the true tales.