1976–1981, 2001–2003Robyn HitchcockVocals, guitar1976–1981, 2001–2003
Morris WindsorDrums1976–1981, 2001–2003
Andy MetcalfeBass1976-1979
Kimberley RewVocals, guitar1976–1981, 2001–2003
Matthew SeligmanBass1979–1981, 2001–2003
The Soft Boys were an English rock group whose mix of pop hooks, British folk rock, and snotty punk aggression made them one of the most beloved cult bands of the post-punk era. Fronted by the surrealistically inclined Robyn Hitchcock, the band wrapped chiming twin guitars and glowing three-part harmonies around grotesque, dreamlike imagery, creating a sound that heavily influenced jangle pop and college rock.
Robyn Hitchcock only ended up in Cambridge by accident. "I had a jam session with someone called Simon Boswell, who was a student and had a record deal with Transatlantic," he told Mojo magazine. "By the time I got to Cambridge he'd left, but I spent three years there finding musicians, meeting Morris Windsor, meeting Kimberley Rew. London was too big for me as a lad with a fragile ego. If I'd been a bit tougher, I'd have just hung on, got into the pub rock scene, met the early punks. But I probably would have wound up where I was anyway."
The band name came before the band. Hitchcock had already written a song called "Give It to the Soft Boys" and saw the Soft Boys as a kind of invisible super-race. "I pictured the Soft Boys a bit like civil servants. They were powerful, but you wouldn't see them," he
explained in a 2002 interview. "My vision of them was that they had been filleted, they had no bones so they could slide under doors and then come back up... They would be bloodless, but they would be alive."
In his own written history of the band, he described his idea as "a tribe of translucent, bloodless man-things that had awesome powers but were largely invisible: stalkers of the hypothalamus, erotic guerrillas."
Hitchcock originally planned to stay out of the spotlight. The initial concept for the band, hatched in 1976, was that a robot would front it while he played guitar behind the scenes. "I wanted to be the Robbie Robertson-style Svengali figure behind the band where we'd have this handsome android fronting it," he recalled to Mojo. "It would have fitted slightly with the science fiction concepts that were percolating, Bowie had a bit of it, but I became my own frontman," a plan he abandoned partly because he is "absolutely and practically inept" and could never have built the thing.
The Soft Boys didn't fit into tribal, late-'70s Britain. Mojo noted the band were "neither punk flesh nor hippy fowl, their fluidity a hard sell in tribal times." Hitchcock later admitted the odds were stacked against them: "I never sought to be on Top of the Pops, but I didn't necessarily seek the degree of obscurity that we have. We were middle-class kids with long hair playing psychedelic music. It's not necessarily going to go down well, is it?"
The band folded in February 1981, though the split was friendly enough. "We broke up because everyone had other things in mind,"
Hitchcock explained to Ondarock. "Kimberley Rew, the guitarist, had a stack of songs that wouldn't have suited that project. Matthew, on the other hand, wanted to test himself in other bands. And I was itching to start my solo career, so as not to remain just a Soft Boy forever. Although, in the end, we stayed Soft anyway." Looking back, he reckons "we really only had one album in us, as a collective."
Hitchcock went on to a prolific solo career, initially with Soft Boys drummer Morris Windsor in his backing band The Egyptians, which also included original Soft Boys bassist Andy Metcalfe. "In the mid-1980s I regrouped with Morris, Andy and others as Robyn Hitchcock and The Egyptians,"
he wrote in an article for The Quietus. "A decade later I reverted to being a 'psychedelic troubadour'... with a floating cast of accomplices, often including old Soft Boys."
Kimberley Rew went on to form Katrina and the Waves after the split. He teamed up with drummer Alex Coope, his old bandmate from The Waves, a Cambridge group Rew had fronted prior to joining the Soft Boys, alongside singer Katrina Leskanich. There he wrote the 1985 smash "
Walking On Sunshine," which was produced by Pat Collier, the same man behind the desk for the Soft Boys'
Underwater Moonlight sessions. Rew later wrote "
Love Shine A Light," which won the 1997 Eurovision Song Contest for the United Kingdom.
Bassist Matthew Seligman, who joined in 1979 in time for Underwater Moonlight, became an in-demand session player, backing David Bowie at Live Aid in 1985 and playing with everyone from Thomas Dolby to Morrissey and Sinéad O'Connor. He later retrained as a human rights lawyer, and died on April 17, 2020, at 64 of COVID-19 complications. Hitchcock remembered him as "a joyous and funky bass player" who "made Underwater Moonlight an exuberant LP to record and listen to."
The Soft Boys' legacy grew steadily after their split as bands like R.E.M. and The Replacements cited them as prime influences. Peter Buck told
Mojo: "I first heard
Underwater Moonlight when R.E.M. was forming."
Their reach extends to The Flaming Lips and Ariel Pink, and
Hitchcock's takeaway is simple: "The great thing is how
Underwater Moonlight has lasted, it vindicates me as a songwriter and The Soft Boys as a band, we did come up with something great in a low-key, low-budget way."
The Soft Boys reunited in 2001 to celebrate Underwater Moonlight's 21st birthday, touring and recording a new album, Nextdoorland, before winding down again in 2003. Hitchcock still regards the band as something that can't quite be pinned down: "The Soft Boys remains, for me, what it always was - a chimera: like a breeze, felt but never seen, from a time long gone."