Comments: 15

• Gary from Los AngelesDespite the narrative that the song meaning is about "peace after war" and was written about a buddy, clearly the song narrative is about a man having some kind of unfulfilment--that he himself is the Broken Arrow. As long ago as 1968, when I myself was ten, I had that image. (Unlike Neil, I am part Native American--though are we not part of a Canadians' sense of identity?)
  
  And my musing is that it is a very personal song based on Neil's own sense of loss about his chronic illness--also reflected in the song "Mr. Soul", the opening lyrics of which were quoted in the original lyrics of this song. In Mr. Soul, clearly the first-person narrative both at once exclaims the thrill of success but speaks of the ashen-faced "clown who is sick (who) does the trick of disaster". Yow.
  
  I can only hope this won't seem like outing you, Mr. Young. It ain't rocket science to see you.
  
  It's almost as if Neil is describing "imposter syndrome", all the more paradoxical as many of us see him as one of the most genuine and authentic musical artists ever. I argue, though, he's been driven to accomplish that exactly because he knows.what it feels like.
  
  Thank you for your body of work, Mr. Young. You are a most valuable social commentator whose melodic bent and ability to find the lost chord, in my opinion, is unsurpassed. You have long been among my favs.
• Gary from Los AngelesGeorge from Vancouver--the Trail of Tears, on the level of a genocide/ethnic cleansing that targeted/disproportionately affected the women and children, displaced the Cherokee, Choctaw, Chickasaw, Creek, and Seminole from the southeastern US to reservations in AR. The Cherokee, who had adopted English style homes and developed their own written language emulating that of the white men, were displaced from GA. This abomination was perpetrated by then President Andrew Jackson, the MF on the $20 USD. The white soldiers of the US Army who were ordered to prod and compell the march of 5,000 miles (GA to AR) were aghast and ashamed to be party to the mistreating of these peoples.
  
  Remember this the next time the orange haired fool waxes poetic about Jackson, who rightly deserved to be hung, quartered, tarred and feathered for his criminal executive act.
• George from Vancouver, CanadaMakes me thinkof the Trail of Tears, whn the Native Indians were marched out of their ancestral territory (Indiana?)
  O rereading the lyrics, now I get the idea it's about a one Indian representing all his race, watching how Hollywood beats up on another treasured tribal memory in favour of making White Amerca the superior. Broken Arrow = "The battle was fought valiantly, & here is my proof, O Great Spirit"
• Tim from Kalamazoo, Mi.Reading Mike's (from Park Ridge) comment about the "heartbeat" at the end of the song made me smile. I have my own little "heartbeat" story.
  
  I was only 3 y/o when this song came out, but within a few years I had mastered my dad's Wollensak reel-to-reel tape recorder. He had the "Retrospective" album as reel-to-reel, and I loved that album - I didn't know about the individual albums for another 8-10 years! Anyway, back in the day (I was about 10 years old), the only way I knew how to record was on my little cassette deck using its portable microphone. And, I used to record a lot of things that way.
  
  Since my parents had divorced years before, I decided I needed that Retrospective album for myself, so on my next visit with my Dad I started recording it. And it turned out really well, all things considered. But the funniest thing happened, and I DID NOT KNOW it until quite a few years later. At the end of Broken Arrow, as the heartbeat started to "fade out", an AIRPLANE flew OVERHEAD, and it FIT IN PERFECTLY to the song, a sort of "thump-thump, thump-thump, thum...-ZOOOOOOOoooooommm----- ... fade out, and it ended JUST IN TIME before the next song (might have been Rock and Roll Woman) started up!! I listened to that little cassette for a long time, and it was only when I was about 17-18 when I bought a well-used "Again" album that I heard the "real thing" again, and REALIZED THERE WAS NO AIRPLANE "ZOOM"!! More than once I wondered what Neil would have thought about my little "addition"!!
• Dave from Vancouver, WaI was listening to this song and it reminded me of The Beatles, "A day in the life." They were both written in 1967. Did one influence the other?
• Mike from Park Ridge , IlWhat was with the heartbeat sound at the end?
• Melissa from Fairborn, OhThis is one of my favorite Buffalo Springfield song which is mostly acoustic on this song, Also, my favorite part of the song I like the most is when I like the jazz touch before the song ends. Yes it's good to waltz to this acoustic/jazz Buffalo Springfield song, hmmm.
• Valerie from Eureka, CaHey Max in Parma Ohio....Yes, this song, Down Down Down is on youtube and is VERY MUCH like Broken Arrow...cool song!!!!! Pioneers were the musicians from the 60's...Down is like a waltz as is Arrow...thanks for mentioning Down, Max.
• Valerie from Eureka, CaNEIL YOUNG!!! He is, in my opinion, a genius! Broken Arrow as all of his songs, is steeped in so much introverted meanings...or so they all seem to be anyway.
• Ted from Phoenix, AzThis is a great song with some very trippy lyrics with obscure meanings. My favorite lines come at the end of the second verse when Neil Young sings: "His mother had said that a trip was a fall And don't mention babies at all.", which i believe is a reference to teenage sexuality.
• Baz from Johnson, VtGreat tune. Though i've always wondered if the US military borrowed the terms Broken Arrow and Empty Quiver for nuclear weapons "incidents" from this song; of course if you're thinking (as Neil and whoever at DoD was making up code names)in that vein it's just as likely to be a coincidence.
• Max from Parma, OhThere's another tune by Buffalo Springfield called "Down Down Down" that has the same melody. Apparently, it was never released on an album in the 1960's, but the Buffalo Springfield boxed set has two different versions of it, demo and remix. I'm not sure if the song has any relations to Broken Arrow, except for a few lyrics and the melody. The first stanza is, "Come to see her in the river/ she'll be there to wave to you/ In the hope that you'll forgive her/ She will join you there."
• Melissa from Fairborn, OhI love the jazz-like part especially at the end of the song.
• Stefanie Magura from Rock Hill, ScI just looked at the lyrics, and this song definitely seems like one Neil Young would write.
• Steve from New York City, NyThis song is a medley. It first starts out with a (seemingly) live version of the Buffalo Springfield song "Mr. Soul" (written by Neil Young). Then it goes into Broken Arrow, "The lights turned on and the curtain fell down...". After this, a jazz quartet plays what sounds like a "jazzified" version of the Broken Arrow melody, complete with piano solo. Finally, it ends with a heartbeat sound (similar to that of "Eclipse" by Pink Floyd five years later).

see more comments