I've Loved Her So Long

Album: Neil Young (1969)
Play Video

Songfacts®:

  • "I've Loved Her So Long" is generally considered one of the highlights of Neil Young's debut album. As Andy Childs wrote in the March 1975 issue of ZigZag, "'The Loner,' 'I've Loved Her So Long' and 'Here We Are In The Years' were near-flawless pieces, acutely tapered and garnished with a side order of strings."
  • The song holds an interesting place in the album, because whereas Young himself plays the tragic figure in most of the other songs, he's the white knight of "I've Loved Her So Long." This time, the role of tragic figure is filled by the sighing woman that "tumbles by" and "rolls along... doing it wrong," all while being a "veteran of a race that should be over."

    It's Young alone that can save her, as he notes that he can "bring her the peace that she needs" and "give her reason to smile." Even here, though, the eerie fatalism that marks much of Young's work is apparent.
  • Many critics have noted the paranoia and desperation that infuses most of the songs on Neil Young. In "The Loner," we have Young as the half-crazed outsider misanthrope. In "If I Could Have her Tonight" we find him looking for a woman to save his life, and in "I've Been Waiting for You" he's so desperate for love that he sounds ready to crack. Only in "I've Loved Her So Long" do we get Young as the gallant hero.

Comments

Be the first to comment...

Editor's Picks

Deconstructing Doors Songs With The Author Of The Doors Examined

Deconstructing Doors Songs With The Author Of The Doors ExaminedSong Writing

Doors expert Jim Cherry, author of The Doors Examined, talks about some of their defining songs and exposes some Jim Morrison myths.

Does Jimmy Page Worship The Devil? A Look at Satanism in Rock

Does Jimmy Page Worship The Devil? A Look at Satanism in RockSong Writing

We ring the Hell's Bells to see what songs and rockers are sincere in their Satanism, and how much of it is an act.

Brandi Carlile

Brandi CarlileSongwriter Interviews

As a 5-year-old, Brandi was writing lyrics to instrumental versions lullabies. She still puts her heart into her songs, including the one Elton John sings on.

Bass Player Scott Edwards

Bass Player Scott EdwardsSong Writing

Scott was Stevie Wonder's bass player before becoming a top session player. Hits he played on include "I Will Survive," "Being With You" and "Sara Smile."

Ian Anderson: "The delight in making music is that you don't have a formula"

Ian Anderson: "The delight in making music is that you don't have a formula"Songwriter Interviews

Ian talks about his 3 or 4 blatant attempts to write a pop song, and also the ones he most connected with, including "Locomotive Breath."

Taylor Dayne

Taylor DayneSongwriter Interviews

Taylor talks about "The Machine" - the hits, the videos and Clive Davis.