This was the love theme to the movie Footloose, starring Kevin Bacon as a city kid who moves to a small town where dancing in public is outlawed. Dean Pitchford wrote the screenplay for the movie and the lyrics to all the songs. He wanted a lot of variety in the music, so he used 7 different co-writers, including Eric Carmen, who wrote this with him. In our interview with Dean Pitchford, he said: "I had a one bedroom bungalow in West Hollywood, and we were seated in the living room, and we were tossing out ideas. I had come in with the title 'Almost Paradise,' because I had been riffing on a lot of titles that had to do with religion and salvation, very much in keeping with the tone of the minister and the preacher and the church background of the motion picture. So 'Almost Paradise' was the given. But I remember sitting there and tossing out lines and coming up with, 'I thought that dreams belonged to other men, because each time I get close they'd fall apart again.' And he liked that very, very much. I was sitting there and I said, 'Oh, how about this, 'I feared my heart would beat in secrecy'?' And he jumped up from the keyboard and he ran over and he hugged me, and he said, 'That's f--king GREAT! That's one of the most brilliant lines I've heard!' And he said, 'We've got to do a lot more of this writing.' And it was that line, 'I feared my heart would beat in secrecy' that sort of joined us at the hip. From that point on, we wrote all day.

That song was written in a day, but in an 11-hour, 12-hour day. The next morning we went into the studio and into the office of our director, who had an upright piano installed in his office specifically to hear all the songs as I created them, with my various collaborators. Eric and I went in and we sang - I brought a girlfriend of mine in to sing the female part, and Eric sang the male part, and that sold that song."

This song's writers Dean Pitchford and Eric Carmen later collaborated on Carmen's 1988 hit "Make Me Lose Control," but this was the first time they worked together. Pitchford told us: "I think Eric was in a kind of a cooling off period in his career and had left his label. He really came roaring back when 'Hungry Eyes' went on to the Dirty Dancing soundtrack, and then Arista signed him up again. He wasn't viable as an artist, but he was one of my favorite, favorite songwriters. I always thought that Eric Carmen was a beautiful melodist. Look at 'Boats Against the Current,' look at 'All By Myself.' Gorgeous, gorgeous stuff. And so he flew in from Ohio and agreed to write with me, but we had no idea who the artist was going to be. But we turned out a song that a lot of people wanted to record, and we were able to get Ann Wilson of Heart and Mike Reno of Loverboy. Being able to snag two of the monster voices in '80s Pop music was a real feather in our cap. But that was simply a case of I knew we needed a ballad, I knew we needed a duet, and I knew that Eric Carmen was the guy to deliver the high emotion of that. And then after that it was just a case of shopping it and we got answers right away, emphatically, from those two."

Eric Carmen said of this song: "That was really the first time that I had collaborated seriously with anybody. The music side of things has always been very easy for me. I had to work really hard on the lyric side. John Kalodner asked me if I'd be interested in writing the love theme from Footloose. I flew out to LA I met Dean Pitchford for breakfast at 7, we went over to Paramount at 9, we watched the film. There was another song plugged into the hole where 'Almost Paradise' was supposed to be. I think it was 'Waiting For A Girl Like You' by Foreigner.
We saw the film, and at noon we were back at Dean's house, and I said, 'Give me one line.' He said, 'Almost paradise, we're knocking at heaven's door.' We spent 12 hours on the song. It was done by midnight. We had to write the bridge the next day and play the song for the people at Paramount. I was amazed - here was a guy who could write lyrics as quickly and as easily as I could write music.
We went and sang it for the producers and directors, and we were terrified. There was a wall in Dean's office, and it had 'Love Theme From Footloose by Dean Pitchford and whoever' and a slash mark through it, and there was another one underneath, and another one underneath that. I looked at that wall the first day, and I said, I will not be another slash mark off 'Love Theme From Footloose' that didn't make it in the movie, with my name sitting there, for the next guy to come in and say, 'Oh, Eric Carmen didn't do it either.'"

This was the fifth of six US Top-40 hits from the movie Footloose; the title track and "Let's Hear It For The Boy" both went to #1. "Almost Paradise" also hit #1 on the Adult Contemporary chart.

Victoria Justice and Hunter Hayes recorded a new version of this song for the 2011 redux of the Footloose movie.