The Logical Song

Album: Breakfast In America (1979)
Charted: 7 6
Play Video
  • When I was young, it seemed that life was so wonderful
    A miracle, oh, it was beautiful, magical
    And all the birds in the trees, well they'd be singing so happily
    Oh, joyfully, oh, playfully watching me
    But then they sent me away to teach me how to be sensible
    Logical, oh, responsible, practical
    Then they showed me a world where I could be so dependable
    Oh, clinical, oh, intellectual, cynical

    There are times when all the world's asleep
    The questions run too deep
    For such a simple man
    Won't you please, please tell me what we've learned?
    I know it sounds absurd
    Please tell me who I am

    I said, now, watch what you say, they'll be calling you a radical
    A liberal, oh, fanatical, criminal
    Oh, won't you sign up your name? We'd like to feel you're acceptable
    Respectable, oh, presentable, a vegetable
    Oh, take, take, take it, yeah

    But at night, when all the world's asleep
    The questions run so deep
    For such a simple man
    Won't you please (oh, won't you tell me)
    Please tell me what we've learned?
    (Can you hear me?) I know it sounds absurd
    (Oh, won't you tell me) please tell me who I am
    Who I am, who I am, who I am


    'Cause I was feeling so logical
    Yeah, one, two, three, five
    Oh, oh, oh, oh, yeah
    Ooh, it's getting unbelievable
    Getting, getting, yeah, yeah
    Uh, uh, uh, uh Writer/s: Richard Davies, Roger Hodgson
    Publisher: Universal Music Publishing Group
    Lyrics licensed and provided by LyricFind

Comments: 43

  • Ardumpax from ArubaAli from Tripoli, Libyan Arab Jamahiriya,
    prophets don't exist.
  • Pincho73 from PoconosWhy would people get on this thread to say they dislike Supertramp and The Logical Song?
    People just like to feel like bad-@$$,especially while hiding behind their keyboards. There is bad-@$$, then there are 'keyboard warriors'.
    I swear this song sums up the lives many of us who got in trouble for asking question in Baptist School. We just got a "Because that's what we said!" " Don't question authority!" as we just wanted them to help us understand...aka...make it LOGICAL.
  • Terence Rendall from Kent EnglandA hall of fame induction is long overdue for supertramp
  • Dudie from IllinoisSome people are rather uptight by nature. They follow all of the rules with an urgency and do not feel comfortable without a full compliment of rules around them to help them know what to do. The educational system seems to favor them. Then there are the artistic type. They aren't as impressed with the rules. They take a look around and breath in deeply and admire nature. They take the long way home. This was probably Roger. They have a hard time developing their personality because society keeps trying to cram it's values down their throats. It is not that Roger wants to be called a Liberal' it is likely that he feared that a bit and knew it was a consequence of following his heart and thinking for himself. But in the end, after all the asking, "tell me who I am," he developed his own firm convictions. There is nothing that I see in the music that trumpets "I am a liberal," except maybe, "Give A Little Bit". I am a conservative and I love him. So what on the politics bit!!!
  • Esskayess from Dallas, TxShould have called it 'The Adjective Song.'
  • Angelmarie from Pleasanton, CaI love this song. It's one of my all time favorites, though I don't really know why since I was made to logical, responsible, and practical, at all times from birth almost. I think it's the, "please tell me who I am" that strikes the cord in people. Without "The Logical Song", people wouldn't be who they are now. I mean that in a good way (thinking about how some people are...).
  • Deethewriter from Saint Petersburg, Russia FederationFormer Supertramp keyboardist and singer Roger Hodgson : "I had the chords to 'Logical Song' and I used to use them in soundcheck with Supertramp. I used to start playing them. And it's funny, I didn't think much of them. And then one day, I started singing and the first word that came in was 'liberal.' And then the song took shape from that. And I didn't realize what I was creating or what had been created, really, until it was finished. Luckily, probably for me, I didn't realize what I was creating at the time. If I thought, 'Boy, this is going to be a monster hit,' I probably would've frozen up and stopped the magic from coming out."
  • Camille from Toronto, OhWas never a Supertramp fan, never understood their popularity, don't particularly care for this song. I turn the channel if it comes on the car stereo. Too much other good music I could be listening to.
  • Gregg from East Rockaway, NyI agree with tod, how dare you liberals say it's nice to be young and enjoy life! You should be old and hateful and be glad about it!
  • Tod from Las Vegas, NvA typical liberal mantra - acting responsible and logical means you are a vegetable. This is such hogwash from a truely rediculous band.
  • Frankie from Galveston, Txeven though this song was released after the Vietnam Conflict was over i believe that this song has references to the draft and men going off to battle. how life was so wonderful and beautiful and so on and so forth, and then how they were sent away to be sensible and such. but thats just my take on it.
  • Wayne from Crockett, TxGreat song, "bought" the Breakfast album through the Columbia Music Club when I was just a kid. And by the way, I believe the 'tweeting' game sound toward the end of this song was made by the handheld Mattel Football game, which I and every other kid had back in the late 70s.
  • Mjn Seifer from Not Listed For Personal Reason, EnglandWhen I first heard this song; I was facing a dificult desision; I had left school and I needed to further my education, and had a choice of doing another year at my previous college or moving away to live-in school very far from my family and friends - I even spent the night there once to see what it was like, but when I came home I was still undecided as to what I should do - and every time my parents would ask me, I would avoid the conversation.

    One night I was lying awake in bed with the radio playing, and this song came on; at first I didn't really notice it, but then I heard the line "But then they sent me away..." and I realized how appropriate this song felt. I listened closley to the song, and suddenly eveything just fell into place for me. I hade made my desision - I was going to stay put, I cared about my friends and family, I was going to stay and get my education here. I am doing a lot better, and I don't think I would have come this far if I had gone to the boarding school (or what ever it was).

    I love this song now, not just 'cause of that, but because it's a great song - I also love Scooter's song "RAMP!" - it contains a sample of this song.
  • Lee from Huntsville, Al1-2-3-5,lol
  • Mary Beth from Level Pebble, Mii love this band they are so original.
  • Glenn from Auckland, New Zealandyes, you can tell a Roger Hodson Penned song, it is typified by his high pitched voice, I remember when this song came out in 1979. I was 11. I took an instant liking to the song, but it wasn't until I really "got" into Supertramp did I really understand the lyrics. Sadly Supertramp weren't the same when Roger Hodson left.
  • Livia from Schaffhausen, SwitzerlandThis song is really true if you listen to the lyrics.
    I'm 17 now and soon I reach the adulthood.
    I remember, when I was a child, you had no sorrows or problems, it was truly "a miracle, beautiful, magical"!
    But suddenly you have to carry responsibility
    and suddenly this world you thought its wonderful, you see this world can sometimes be really hard.
    So you asking yourself: "Who am I?" in this world. Where's my place, where should I go?
    He sings: "Please tell me what we've learned" could be he wants to remember how exactly the life as child was... don't know.
    It's normal that children say what they want and think, but when you're gettin older you have to "watch what you say". Even my mother told me that when I was about 6 or 7, cause many adults don't like to hear the truth.
    But if you "sign up your name" in the world of the adults, you will be acceptable, respectable, presentable... but I'll not gonna be a vegetable, I'll take care ;)
    So you see, that's what I think about the song and it's my song to grow up.
    Someday I'll maybe play this song to my child when she/he is at my age ;)
  • Stefanie from England, United KingdomThe song lyrics also suggest signs of suggesting mental illness and confusion about how real things are.

    Wonderful song, one of my faves!
  • Ali from Tripoli, Libyan Arab JamahiriyaWhat a song, we grow up we begin to search for the truth. who are we? who made us? what does he want from us? where we are to? we need to know the answers.the answers came with the prophets, among them are Noan, Ibraha, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad.
  • Mirna from Portoviejo, Ecuadorirony of life
  • John from Notre Dame, In"At night, when all the world's asleep,/
    the questions run so deep/
    for such a simple man./
    Won't you please, please tell me what we've learned/
    I know it sounds absurd/
    but please tell me who I am/

    Maybe many would disagree but I always thought the refrain was religious/spiritual. All the world is asleep and he is facing the deep meaning of life and calls out "Please tell me who I am." That doesnt sound like a man talking to himself. What do others think?

    This is an all-time fav of mine. I was 14 when it came out and dealing with a very intense high-pressure school etc. This song got me through freshman year. Many thanks to the band for helping me through.
  • Jeff from Atlanta, GaOne of the things i love about Supertramp is the duality of the songwriters. Just as u can always tell a Lennon from a McCartney.. or a Henley from a Frey.. u can tell a Hodgson from a Davies.
    I was ten when this was out. I loved it then.. kind of thought of it as a idealistic person being steadily beaten down by circumstances and those around him. Would love to see a Tramp reunion!
  • James from Gettysburg, PaI'm with Scott. It was the perfect song for the transition from HS to college. I called myself the man-child at the time.
  • Scott from Palm Desert, CaThis song was right after my HS graduation and as i was making that transition to adulthood. This entire L.P. reminds me of that time and has a special place in my heart.
  • Jim from Stonerville, Cait took me forever to figure out who this was by. supertramp is probably the most famous band that no one has heard of.
  • Jason from Dublin, Irelandthe german electronic band scooter covered this song and it reached no1 in ireland but i think it really was no patch on the original.
  • Joe from Fort Meade, MdYeah "Electronic Football" was a big deal back then. I remember playing that thing as a kid, it was my Dad's, he's always been big on technology.

    As for the song. Like a lot of the posters on here until I was about 18 or so, I liked this song based off the fact that it had a GREAT sound, acoustically pleasing to the ear. Then I listened to the words one time and it clicked that this was the anthem for the teenager. I have liked the song that much more since then.

    And yes Phil, I remember that episode. There are a few episodes where Homer makes some GREAT musical references.
  • Lobstarock from Boston, MaThis song came out the year of my highschool graduation. Hearing this songs brings me back to the summer of possibilities. Hanging out and drinking beers down at my friend's parent's cottage on the Cape, before saying goodbye, to some, forever.
  • Justin from Albany, Nygreat song by a great band! and eric i agree with you it does sort of sound like this song was written for the giver.
  • Lynn from Redfield, SdThere was also a parody of this song called "The topical song". It was about the gas shortage of the late 70's.
  • Eric from Davis, CaHas anyone read the book "the giver"? it really sounds like the song was written about the book, i know that thats probably not true, but ya..
  • Alan from Akron, OhI remember hearing this song when I was like 10 or something and I thought that the song was about rhyming words that ended with "al's and "ables"(remarkABLE, locicAL, you get the picture) As I was sitting in class one day listening to my radio I heard the song thinking it was that dang rhyming song again. This time I payed close attention to the lyrics, and I realized that the song was about me(not really) but, it was about what kids discover what the world is really like. It isn't just fun and games, its buisness, and every man for themselves.

    steph, Ottawa, Canada
    I have to agree with you that is one of my favorite lyrics too, because's true.
  • Casey from Pensacola, FlI always loved the sax solo in this song. I heard it was recorded in the men's room of the recording studio.
  • Stefanie from Rock Hill, ScWhat a great song. I'm a teenager so I feel like I can identify with it some.
  • Donald from Festus, Mothis song is great at capturing the fellig almost everyone has about going from a child to a part of "the machine". I think it is mostly based on the teen years when, in a short time, you go from a fun-loving kid to hard-working adult. It is the song for the word "jaded"
  • Johny from Somewhere Else, IlYeah, the synth they use is really hot. Must be a whirly or Vintage Electric Piano. defiantly one of the reasons i like the song.
  • Paul Serrato from Arlington, TxThis Is One Of The Best Bands Of The World!!!
  • Phil from Niagara Falls, Canadawho rmemeber that one simspons epiisode where homer explains what was lia's firstword "the 80s was a wonderful decade, the rise of supertramp..." and then you see young homer working at a putting range and this onsg is playing
  • Scott from Chicago, Ilsounds more appropriate today in the "bush" years
    then it ever did...."the questions run so deep for such a simple man", indeed.....
  • Ocean from Amsterdam, NetherlandsThere's also a cover version of it by 'Double Date' a Dutch ugly twinsisters act from the nineties. Don't try the find the song; if you hear it, you'll probably die...
  • Mike from Jacksonville, FlI remember when life was so wonderful, a miracle
    now I'm just jaded. This song reminds me of my former self. Listen carefully.
  • Marlow from Perth, Australiaclassic song. classic band!
  • Charles from Charlotte, NcThis is a song that laments the loss of idealism. The band bought the special organ for the keyboard part just for this song.
see more comments

Editor's Picks


LecraeSongwriter Interviews

The Christian rapper talks about where his trip to Haiti and his history of addiction fit into his songs.

Wherefore Art Thou Romeo Lyric

Wherefore Art Thou Romeo LyricMusic Quiz

In this quiz, spot the artist who put Romeo into a song lyric.

Michael Sweet of Stryper

Michael Sweet of StryperSongwriter Interviews

Find out how God and glam metal go together from the Stryper frontman.

Brian Kehew: The Man Behind The Remasters

Brian Kehew: The Man Behind The RemastersSong Writing

Brian has unearthed outtakes by Fleetwood Mac, Aretha Franklin, Elvis Costello and hundreds of other artists for reissues. Here's how he does it.

Alan Merrill of The Arrows

Alan Merrill of The ArrowsSongwriter Interviews

In her days with The Runaways, Joan Jett saw The Arrows perform "I Love Rock And Roll," which Alan Merrill co-wrote - that story and much more from this glam rock pioneer.

Meshell Ndegeocello

Meshell NdegeocelloSongwriter Interviews

Meshell Ndegeocello talks about recording "Wild Night" with John Mellencamp, and explains why she shied away from the spotlight.